Progress: Procedure rejected
Subjects
Events
The European Parliament rejected two motions for resolution presented pursuant to Rule 108(2) of the Rules of Procedure on seeking an opinion from the Court of Justice on the compatibility with the Treaties of the Agreement between the United States of America and the European Union on the protection of personal information relating to the prevention, investigation, detection, and prosecution of criminal offenses.
1) In the first motion for resolution , presented by the GUE/NGL group (and rejected by 165 votes to 442, with 36 abstention), Members considered that that there is legal uncertainty as to whether the draft agreement is compatible with the provisions of the Treaties (Article 16 of the TFEU) and the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union (Articles 7, 8 and 52(1) as regards the right of individuals to protection of personal data and Article 47 as regards the availability of an effective judicial remedy).
Members at the origin of the motion for resolution noted that:
according to the European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS), there are concerns that the supervisory data protection authorities (DPAs) in the US do not meet the Court of Justice requirements for being considered fully independent and with effective powers of intervention; the US Judicial Redress Act does not overturn the existing exemptions to data subject rights which certain systems of records in the US may provide pursuant to the US Privacy Act, such as PNR data; Parliament’s Legal Service has pointed out that the EU-US Umbrella Agreement (specifically Article 5(3)) will serve as a form of adequacy decision, creating a ‘ de iure ’ legal presumption of compliance by the US with EU data protection standards and potentially undermining real compliance with EU Data Protection law.
2) In this second motion for resolution , presented by the ALDE group (and rejected by 206 votes to 394, with 42 abstentions), Members considered that there is legal uncertainty as to whether the agreement is compatible with the provisions of the Treaties (Article 16) and the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union (Articles 7, 8, 21, 47 and 52(1)) as regards the right of individuals to protection of personal data, the principle of non-discrimination and the right to an effective remedy and to a fair trial.
Members at the origin of the motion for resolution noted that:
to date, the European Union or its Member States have not been designated by the US Department of Justice as a ‘covered country’ for its citizens to be able to bring civil actions against certain US government agencies under the Privacy Act of 1974; the judicial remedies afforded by the US Judicial Redress Act would not be granted to non-EU nationals in the Union whose personal data are processed and transferred to the US pursuant to the Agreement; the current US legislation includes various limitations and preconditions as to the scope of application, the causes of action provided, the designation of agencies covered, and the application of the Privacy Act of 1974 in law enforcement matters; personal data processed on the basis of the EU-US Agreement on Passenger Name Records (PNR) and the EU-US Agreement on the processing and transfer of Financial Messaging Data from the EU to the US for the purposes of the Terrorist Finance Tracking Program (TFTP) are currently exempted from the provisions on civil remedies under the Privacy Act of 1974.
Members considered that:
attention should be paid to the following points: the definitions of the concepts of ‘personal data’ and ‘data processing’ differ from the EU definitions; the data retention period should be defined more strictly in relation to the purpose pursued; the restrictions to an individual’s access rights are very broad and access could be improved by the establishment of an indirect access right mechanism.
Documents
- Motion for a resolution: B8-1304/2016
- Motion for a resolution: B8-1305/2016
- Results of vote in Parliament: Results of vote in Parliament
- Motion for a resolution: B8-1304/2016
- Motion for a resolution: B8-1305/2016
Activities
- Marina ALBIOL GUZMÁN
- Marie-Christine ARNAUTU
- Jonathan ARNOTT
- Zoltán BALCZÓ
- Zigmantas BALČYTIS
- Hugues BAYET
- Xabier BENITO ZILUAGA
- Marie-Christine BOUTONNET
- Steeve BRIOIS
- James CARVER
- Nicola CAPUTO
- Alberto CIRIO
- Edward CZESAK
- William (The Earl of) DARTMOUTH
- Rachida DATI
- Gérard DEPREZ
- Mireille D'ORNANO
- Georgios EPITIDEIOS
- Doru-Claudian FRUNZULICĂ
- Francisco de Paula GAMBUS MILLET
- Bruno GOLLNISCH
- Tania GONZÁLEZ PEÑAS
- Marian HARKIN
- Ivan JAKOVČIĆ
- Philippe JUVIN
- Barbara KAPPEL
- Ivana MALETIĆ
- Dominique MARTIN
- Notis MARIAS
- Valentinas MAZURONIS
- Angelika MLINAR
- Louis MICHEL
- Sophie MONTEL
- Franz OBERMAYR
- Rolandas PAKSAS
- Marijana PETIR
- Franck PROUST
- Julia REID
- Fernando RUAS
- Jill SEYMOUR
- Maria Lidia SENRA RODRÍGUEZ
- Siôn SIMON
- Beatrix von STORCH
- Patricija ŠULIN
- Eleftherios SYNADINOS
- Claudia ȚAPARDEL
- Ivica TOLIĆ
- Ramon TREMOSA i BALCELLS
- Miguel VIEGAS
- Cecilia WIKSTRÖM
Votes
B8-1304/2016 #
Verts/ALE
GUE/NGL
ENF
EFDD
NI
ECR
ALDE
S&D
PPEB8-1305/2016 #
History
(these mark the time of scraping, not the official date of the change)
| docs/0/docs/0/url |
Old
http://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/B-8-2016-1304_EN.htmlNew
https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/B-8-2016-1304_EN.html |
| docs/1/docs/0/url |
Old
http://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/B-8-2016-1305_EN.htmlNew
https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/B-8-2016-1305_EN.html |
| events/1/type |
Old
Decision by Parliament, 1st reading/single readingNew
Decision by Parliament |
| procedure/Modified legal basis |
Rules of Procedure EP 114-p6
|
| procedure/Other legal basis |
Rules of Procedure EP 114-p6
|
| docs/0/docs/0/url |
Old
http://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getDoc.do?type=MOTION&reference=B8-2016-1304&language=ENNew
http://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/B-8-2016-1304_EN.html |
| docs/1/docs/0/url |
Old
http://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getDoc.do?type=MOTION&reference=B8-2016-1305&language=ENNew
http://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/B-8-2016-1305_EN.html |
| procedure/Modified legal basis |
Old
Rules of Procedure EP 108-p6New
Rules of Procedure EP 114-p6 |
| activities |
|
| committees |
|
| docs |
|
| events |
|
| links |
|
| other |
|
| procedure/Modified legal basis |
Old
Rules of Procedure of the European Parliament EP 108-p6New
Rules of Procedure EP 108-p6 |
| procedure/subject |
Old
New
|
| procedure/subtype |
Old
Resolution on statementsNew
|
| procedure/summary |
|
| activities/0 |
|
| procedure/stage_reached |
Old
Awaiting Parliament 1st reading / single reading / budget 1st stageNew
Procedure rejected |
| activities/0 |
|
| activities |
|
| committees |
|
| links |
|
| other |
|
| procedure |
|