Events

Documents

• Text adopted by Parliament, single reading: T9-0397/2023
• Decision by Parliament: T9-0397/2023
• Motion for a resolution: B9-0453/2023
• Motion for a resolution: B9-0454/2023
• Motion for a resolution: B9-0455/2023
• Motion for a resolution: B9-0456/2023
• Motion for a resolution: B9-0457/2023
• Debate in Parliament: Debate in Parliament
• Motion for a resolution: B9-0453/2023
• Motion for a resolution: B9-0454/2023
• Motion for a resolution: B9-0455/2023
• Motion for a resolution: B9-0456/2023
• Motion for a resolution: B9-0457/2023
• Text adopted by Parliament, single reading: T9-0397/2023

Activities

• Pina PICIERNO
  Plenary Speeches (2)

  • 2023/11/09 Effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia (RC-B9-0453/2023, B9-0453/2023, B9-0454/2023, B9-0455/2023, B9-0456/2023, B9-0457/2023) (vote)
  • 2023/11/09 Effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia (RC-B9-0453/2023, B9-0453/2023, B9-0454/2023, B9-0455/2023, B9-0456/2023, B9-0457/2023)
• Eugen TOMAC
  Plenary Speeches (1)

  • 2023/11/09 Effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia (RC-B9-0453/2023, B9-0453/2023, B9-0454/2023, B9-0455/2023, B9-0456/2023, B9-0457/2023)

  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Petras AUŠTREVIČIUS
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Adam BIELAN
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Ryszard CZARNECKI
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Angel DZHAMBAZKI
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Anna FOTYGA
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Michael GAHLER
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Andrey KOVATCHEV
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Georgios KYRTSOS
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Javier NART
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Urmas PAET
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Tonino PICULA
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Jacek SARYUSZ-WOLSKI
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Henna VIRKKUNEN
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Anders VISTISEN
  Plenary Speeches (1)

  • 2023/11/09 Effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia (RC-B9-0453/2023, B9-0453/2023, B9-0454/2023, B9-0455/2023, B9-0456/2023, B9-0457/2023)
• Jadwiga WIŚNIEWSKA
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Kosma ZŁOTOWSKI
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Sergey LAGODINSKY
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Nathalie LOISEAU
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Pedro MARQUES
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Alexander ALEXANDROV YORDANOV
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Traian BĂSESCU
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Vladimír BILČÍK
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Saskia BRICMONT
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Anna CAVAZZINI
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Olivier CHASTEL
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Katalin CSEH
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Bernard GUETTA
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Andrzej HALICKI
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Assita KANKO
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Arba KOKALARI
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Andrius KUBILIUS
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Dragoş PÎSLARU
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Ivan Vilibor SINČIĆ
  Plenary Speeches (1)

  • 2023/11/09 Effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia (RC-B9-0453/2023, B9-0453/2023, B9-0454/2023, B9-0455/2023, B9-0456/2023, B9-0457/2023)
• Hermann TERTSCH
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Dragoş TUDORACHE
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Alexandr VONDRA
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Veronika VRECIONOVÁ
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Mick WALLACE
  Plenary Speeches (1)

  • 2023/11/09 Effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia (RC-B9-0453/2023, B9-0453/2023, B9-0454/2023, B9-0455/2023, B9-0456/2023, B9-0457/2023)
• Witold Jan WASZCZYKOWSKI
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Isabel WISELER-LIMA
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Francisco GUERREIRO
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Karin KARLSBRO
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Karen MELCHIOR
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Anna ZALEWSKA
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Eugen JURZYCA
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Joachim Stanisław BRUDZIŃSKI
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Bogdan RZOŃCA
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Cristian TERHEŞ
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Rasa JUKNEVIČIENĖ
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Elżbieta RAFALSKA
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Mounir SATOURI
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Radosław SIKORSKI
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Sara SKYTTEDAL
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Janina OCHOJSKA
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Vlad GHEORGHE
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia
• Thijs REUTEN
  Institutional Motions (1)

  • 2023/11/06 MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION on the effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia

Votes

Effectiveness of the EU sanctions on Russia – RC-B9-0453/2023 – After § 8 – Am 2 #

		PL	HU	LV	EE	FI	CY	CZ	MT	LU	BG	LT	HR	SK	SE	SI	IE	EL	IT	DK	NL	BE	PT	RO	AT	ES	FR	DE
	Total	47	17	6	5	10	4	20	5	5	12	9	10	13	17	8	12	14	63	13	25	21	16	21	17	49	62	78
ECR	64	Poland ECR For (25) Adam BIELAN, Andżelika Anna MOŻDŻANOWSKA, Anna FOTYGA, Anna ZALEWSKA, Beata KEMPA, Beata MAZUREK, Beata SZYDŁO, Bogdan RZOŃCA, Dominik TARCZYŃSKI, Elżbieta KRUK, Elżbieta RAFALSKA, Grzegorz TOBISZOWSKI, Izabela-Helena KLOC, Jacek SARYUSZ-WOLSKI, Jadwiga WIŚNIEWSKA, Joachim Stanisław BRUDZIŃSKI, Joanna KOPCIŃSKA, Karol KARSKI, Kosma ZŁOTOWSKI, Krzysztof JURGIEL, Patryk JAKI, Ryszard Antoni LEGUTKO, Ryszard CZARNECKI, Witold Jan WASZCZYKOWSKI, Zdzisław KRASNODĘBSKI 25		Latvia ECR For (1) Roberts ZĪLE 1		Finland ECR For (2) Pirkko RUOHONEN-LERNER, Teuvo HAKKARAINEN 2		Czechia ECR For (4) Alexandr VONDRA, Evžen TOŠENOVSKÝ, Jan ZAHRADIL, Veronika VRECIONOVÁ 4			Bulgaria ECR For (2) Andrey SLABAKOV, Angel DZHAMBAZKI 2		Croatia ECR For (1) Ladislav ILČIĆ 1	Slovakia ECR For (1) Eugen JURZYCA 1	Sweden ECR For (3) Charlie WEIMERS, Johan NISSINEN, Peter LUNDGREN 3			Greece ECR Abstain (1) Emmanouil FRAGKOS 1	Italy ECR For (9) Carlo FIDANZA, Chiara GEMMA, Elisabetta DE BLASIS, Giuseppe MILAZZO, Nicola PROCACCINI, Pietro FIOCCHI, Raffaele STANCANELLI, Sergio BERLATO, Vincenzo SOFO Against (1) Denis NESCI 10		Netherlands ECR For (2) Dorien ROOKMAKER, Michiel HOOGEVEEN Abstain (3) Bert-Jan RUISSEN, Rob ROOKEN, Robert ROOS 5	Belgium ECR For (2) Geert BOURGEOIS, Johan VAN OVERTVELDT Abstain (1) Assita KANKO 3		Romania ECR For (1) Cristian TERHEŞ 1		Spain ECR For (4) Hermann TERTSCH, Jorge BUXADÉ VILLALBA, Margarita DE LA PISA CARRIÓN, Mazaly AGUILAR 4		Germany ECR For (1) Lars Patrick BERG 1
NI	38		Hungary NI Abstain (11) Andor DELI, Andrea BOCSKOR, Balázs HIDVÉGHI, Edina TÓTH, Enikő GYŐRI, Ernő SCHALLER-BAROSS, Kinga GÁL, László TRÓCSÁNYI, Lívia JÁRÓKA, Tamás DEUTSCH, Ádám KÓSA 11	Latvia NI Against (1) Tatjana ŽDANOKA 1									Croatia NI Abstain (1) Ivan Vilibor SINČIĆ 1	Slovakia NI Against (4) Katarína ROTH NEVEĎALOVÁ, Milan UHRÍK, Miroslav RADAČOVSKÝ, Monika BEŇOVÁ 4				Greece NI Against (1) Alexis GEORGOULIS Abstain (3) Eva KAILI, Kostas PAPADAKIS, Lefteris NIKOLAOU-ALAVANOS 4	Italy NI For (7) Dino GIARRUSSO, Fabio Massimo CASTALDO, Laura FERRARA, Maria Angela DANZÌ, Mario FURORE, Sabrina PIGNEDOLI, Tiziana BEGHIN Against (2) Andrea COZZOLINO, Francesca DONATO 9		Netherlands NI Against (1) Marcel de GRAAFF 1	Belgium NI Against (1) Marc TARABELLA 1				Spain NI Abstain (3) Antoni COMÍN I OLIVERES, Carles PUIGDEMONT I CASAMAJÓ, Clara PONSATÍ OBIOLS 3	France NI Against (1) Hervé JUVIN 1	Germany NI Against (2) Jörg MEUTHEN, Martin BUSCHMANN 2
The Left	24						Cyprus The Left Against (1) Giorgos GEORGIOU 1	Czechia The Left Against (1) Kateřina KONEČNÁ 1							Sweden The Left Against (1) Malin BJÖRK 1		Ireland The Left For (1) Chris MACMANUS Against (3) Clare DALY, Luke Ming FLANAGAN, Mick WALLACE 4	Greece The Left Against (3) Dimitrios PAPADIMOULIS, Konstantinos ARVANITIS, Petros KOKKALIS 3		Denmark The Left Against (1) Nikolaj VILLUMSEN 1	Netherlands The Left For (1) Anja HAZEKAMP 1	Belgium The Left Against (1) Marc BOTENGA 1	Portugal The Left For (1) José GUSMÃO Against (2) João PIMENTA LOPES, Sandra PEREIRA 3			Spain The Left Against (2) Manu PINEDA, Sira REGO 2	France The Left Abstain (3) Anne-Sophie PELLETIER, Emmanuel MAUREL, Leila CHAIBI 3	Germany The Left Against (3) Helmut SCHOLZ, Martin SCHIRDEWAN, Özlem DEMIREL 3
ID	50				Estonia ID For (1) Jaak MADISON 1			Czechia ID Against (1) Ivan DAVID 1											Italy ID Abstain (18) Alessandro PANZA, Angelo CIOCCA, Anna BONFRISCO, Annalisa TARDINO, Antonio Maria RINALDI, Danilo Oscar LANCINI, Elena LIZZI, Gianantonio DA RE, Gianna GANCIA, Marco CAMPOMENOSI, Maria Veronica ROSSI, Matteo GAZZINI, Paola GHIDONI, Paolo BORCHIA, Rosanna CONTE, Silvia SARDONE, Susanna CECCARDI, Valentino GRANT 18	Denmark ID For (1) Anders VISTISEN 1		Belgium ID Abstain (3) Filip DE MAN, Gerolf ANNEMANS, Tom VANDENDRIESSCHE 3			Austria ID Against (3) Georg MAYER, Harald VILIMSKY, Roman HAIDER 3		France ID Against (15) André ROUGÉ, Annika BRUNA, Aurélia BEIGNEUX, Catherine GRISET, Dominique BILDE, France JAMET, Gilles LEBRETON, Jean-Paul GARRAUD, Jordan BARDELLA, Marie DAUCHY, Mathilde ANDROUËT, Patricia CHAGNON, Philippe OLIVIER, Thierry MARIANI, Virginie JORON 15	Germany ID Against (8) Bernhard ZIMNIOK, Christine ANDERSON, Guido REIL, Gunnar BECK, Joachim KUHS, Markus BUCHHEIT, Nicolaus FEST, Sylvia LIMMER 8
Verts/ALE	65	Poland Verts/ALE Against (1) Sylwia SPUREK 1				Finland Verts/ALE Against (3) Alviina ALAMETSÄ, Heidi HAUTALA, Ville NIINISTÖ 3		Czechia Verts/ALE Against (3) Marcel KOLAJA, Markéta GREGOROVÁ, Mikuláš PEKSA 3				Lithuania Verts/ALE For (1) Bronis ROPĖ Against (1) Stasys JAKELIŪNAS 2			Sweden Verts/ALE Against (3) Alice KUHNKE, Jakop G. DALUNDE, Pär HOLMGREN 3		Ireland Verts/ALE Against (1) Ciarán CUFFE 1		Italy Verts/ALE Against (3) Ignazio CORRAO, Piernicola PEDICINI, Rosa D'AMATO 3	Denmark Verts/ALE Against (2) Kira Marie PETER-HANSEN, Margrete AUKEN 2	Netherlands Verts/ALE Against (3) Bas EICKHOUT, Kim VAN SPARRENTAK, Tineke STRIK 3	Belgium Verts/ALE Against (3) Philippe LAMBERTS, Sara MATTHIEU, Saskia BRICMONT 3	Portugal Verts/ALE Against (1) Francisco GUERREIRO 1		Austria Verts/ALE Against (3) Monika VANA, Sarah WIENER, Thomas WAITZ 3	Spain Verts/ALE Against (4) Ana MIRANDA, Diana RIBA I GINER, Ernest URTASUN, Jordi SOLÉ 4	France Verts/ALE Against (12) Benoît BITEAU, Caroline ROOSE, Claude GRUFFAT, Damien CARÊME, David CORMAND, François ALFONSI, Gwendoline DELBOS-CORFIELD, Karima DELLI, Lydie MASSARD, Marie TOUSSAINT, Michèle RIVASI, Mounir SATOURI 12	Germany Verts/ALE Against (21) Alexandra GEESE, Anna CAVAZZINI, Anna DEPARNAY-GRUNENBERG, Damian BOESELAGER, Daniel FREUND, Erik MARQUARDT, Hannah NEUMANN, Henrike HAHN, Jutta PAULUS, Malte GALLÉE, Manuela RIPA, Martin HÄUSLING, Michael BLOSS, Nico SEMSROTT, Niklas NIENASS, Patrick BREYER, Pierrette HERZBERGER-FOFANA, Rasmus ANDRESEN, Sergey LAGODINSKY, Ska KELLER, Terry REINTKE 21
Renew	86	Poland Renew Against (1) Róża THUN UND HOHENSTEIN 1	Hungary Renew Against (1) Katalin CSEH 1	Latvia Renew For (1) Ivars IJABS 1	Estonia Renew Against (3) Andrus ANSIP, Jana TOOM, Urmas PAET 3	Finland Renew For (1) Mauri PEKKARINEN Against (1) Nils TORVALDS 2		Czechia Renew Against (5) Dita CHARANZOVÁ, Martin HLAVÁČEK, Martina DLABAJOVÁ, Ondřej KNOTEK, Ondřej KOVAŘÍK 5		Luxembourg Renew Against (2) Charles GOERENS, Monica SEMEDO 2	Bulgaria Renew Against (3) Atidzhe ALIEVA-VELI, Ilhan KYUCHYUK, Iskra MIHAYLOVA 3	Lithuania Renew Abstain (1) Petras AUŠTREVIČIUS 1	Croatia Renew Against (1) Valter FLEGO 1	Slovakia Renew Against (4) Jozef MIHÁL, Lucia ĎURIŠ NICHOLSONOVÁ, Martin HOJSÍK, Michal WIEZIK 4	Sweden Renew For (1) Karin KARLSBRO Against (2) Abir AL-SAHLANI, Emma WIESNER 3	Slovenia Renew Against (2) Irena JOVEVA, Klemen GROŠELJ 2	Ireland Renew Against (2) Barry ANDREWS, Billy KELLEHER 2	Greece Renew Against (1) Georgios KYRTSOS 1	Italy Renew Against (2) Giuseppe FERRANDINO, Marco ZULLO 2	Denmark Renew Against (5) Asger CHRISTENSEN, Bergur Løkke RASMUSSEN, Karen MELCHIOR, Morten LØKKEGAARD, Morten PETERSEN 5	Netherlands Renew For (1) Catharina RINZEMA Against (6) Bart GROOTHUIS, Caroline NAGTEGAAL, Jan HUITEMA, Malik AZMANI, Samira RAFAELA, Sophia IN 'T VELD 7	Belgium Renew Against (4) Frédérique RIES, Guy VERHOFSTADT, Hilde VAUTMANS, Olivier CHASTEL 4		Romania Renew Against (4) Dragoş PÎSLARU, Dragoş TUDORACHE, Ramona STRUGARIU, Vlad GHEORGHE 4		Spain Renew Against (8) Adrián VÁZQUEZ LÁZARA, Izaskun BILBAO BARANDICA, Javier NART, Jordi CAÑAS, José Ramón BAUZÁ DÍAZ, Maite PAGAZAURTUNDÚA, María Soraya RODRÍGUEZ RAMOS, Susana SOLÍS PÉREZ 8	France Renew For (1) Ilana CICUREL Against (17) Bernard GUETTA, Catherine AMALRIC, Christophe GRUDLER, Dominique RIQUET, Fabienne KELLER, Gilles BOYER, Irène TOLLERET, Jérémy DECERLE, Laurence FARRENG, Nathalie LOISEAU, Pascal CANFIN, Pierre KARLESKIND, Salima YENBOU, Sandro GOZI, Stéphane SÉJOURNÉ, Stéphanie YON-COURTIN, Valérie HAYER 18	Germany Renew Against (6) Andreas GLÜCK, Engin EROGLU, Jan-Christoph OETJEN, Moritz KÖRNER, Svenja HAHN, Ulrike MÜLLER 6
S&D	106	Poland S&D For (4) Marek BELKA, Marek Paweł BALT, Robert BIEDROŃ, Łukasz KOHUT Against (2) Bogusław LIBERADZKI, Leszek MILLER 6	Hungary S&D For (4) Attila ARA-KOVÁCS, Csaba MOLNÁR, Klára DOBREV, Sándor RÓNAI Against (1) István UJHELYI 5	Latvia S&D Against (1) Nils UŠAKOVS 1		Finland S&D Against (2) Eero HEINÄLUOMA, Miapetra KUMPULA-NATRI 2	Cyprus S&D Against (1) Demetris PAPADAKIS 1	Czechia S&D Against (1) Radka MAXOVÁ 1	Malta S&D Against (4) Alex AGIUS SALIBA, Alfred SANT, Cyrus ENGERER, Josianne CUTAJAR 4	Luxembourg S&D Against (1) Marc ANGEL 1		Lithuania S&D Against (2) Juozas OLEKAS, Vilija BLINKEVIČIŪTĖ 2	Croatia S&D Against (4) Biljana BORZAN, Predrag Fred MATIĆ, Romana JERKOVIĆ, Tonino PICULA 4	Slovakia S&D Against (1) Robert HAJŠEL 1	Sweden S&D For (1) Evin INCIR Against (3) Carina OHLSSON, Heléne FRITZON, Ilan DE BASSO 4	Slovenia S&D Against (2) Matjaž NEMEC, Milan BRGLEZ 2			Italy S&D For (1) Brando BENIFEI Against (11) Achille VARIATI, Alessandra MORETTI, Beatrice COVASSI, Daniela RONDINELLI, Elisabetta GUALMINI, Irene TINAGLI, Massimiliano SMERIGLIO, Mercedes BRESSO, Paolo DE CASTRO, Pietro BARTOLO, Pina PICIERNO 12	Denmark S&D Against (3) Christel SCHALDEMOSE, Marianne VIND, Niels FUGLSANG 3	Netherlands S&D Against (3) Agnes JONGERIUS, Mohammed CHAHIM, Thijs REUTEN 3	Belgium S&D Against (2) Kathleen VAN BREMPT, Maria ARENA 2	Portugal S&D Against (7) Carlos ZORRINHO, Isabel CARVALHAIS, Isabel SANTOS, João ALBUQUERQUE, Margarida MARQUES, Pedro SILVA PEREIRA, Sara CERDAS 7	Romania S&D Against (4) Adrian-Dragoş BENEA, Maria GRAPINI, Mihai TUDOSE, Rovana PLUMB Abstain (2) Tudor CIUHODARU, Victor NEGRESCU 6	Austria S&D Against (5) Andreas SCHIEDER, Evelyn REGNER, Günther SIDL, Hannes HEIDE, Theresa BIELOWSKI 5	Spain S&D Against (17) Alicia HOMS GINEL, Clara AGUILERA, Cristina MAESTRE MARTÍN DE ALMAGRO, César LUENA, Domènec RUIZ DEVESA, Eider GARDIAZABAL RUBIAL, Ibán GARCÍA DEL BLANCO, Inma RODRÍGUEZ-PIÑERO, Iratxe GARCÍA PÉREZ, Isabel GARCÍA MUÑOZ, Javier MORENO SÁNCHEZ, Jonás FERNÁNDEZ, Laura BALLARÍN CEREZA, Marcos ROS SEMPERE, Mónica Silvana GONZÁLEZ, Nacho SÁNCHEZ AMOR, Nicolás GONZÁLEZ CASARES 17	France S&D For (1) Pascal DURAND Against (6) Aurore LALUCQ, Christophe CLERGEAU, Nora MEBAREK, Pierre LARROUTUROU, Raphaël GLUCKSMANN, Sylvie GUILLAUME 7	Germany S&D Against (10) Bernd LANGE, Delara BURKHARDT, Jens GEIER, Karsten LUCKE, Matthias ECKE, Petra KAMMEREVERT, René REPASI, Thomas RUDNER, Tiemo WÖLKEN, Udo BULLMANN 10
PPE	146	Poland PPE For (9) Adam JARUBAS, Andrzej HALICKI, Elżbieta Katarzyna ŁUKACIJEWSKA, Ewa KOPACZ, Jan OLBRYCHT, Janina OCHOJSKA, Jarosław KALINOWSKI, Radosław SIKORSKI, Tomasz FRANKOWSKI Against (4) Danuta Maria HÜBNER, Jarosław DUDA, Jerzy BUZEK, Magdalena ADAMOWICZ Abstain (1) Janusz LEWANDOWSKI 14		Latvia PPE Against (2) Inese VAIDERE, Sandra KALNIETE 2	Estonia PPE Against (1) Riho TERRAS 1	Finland PPE Against (1) Sirpa PIETIKÄINEN 1	Cyprus PPE Against (2) Eleni STAVROU, Loucas FOURLAS 2	Czechia PPE For (3) Jiří POSPÍŠIL, Michaela ŠOJDROVÁ, Tomáš ZDECHOVSKÝ Against (1) Stanislav POLČÁK Abstain (1) Luděk NIEDERMAYER 5	Malta PPE Against (1) David CASA 1	Luxembourg PPE Against (2) Isabel WISELER-LIMA, Martine KEMP 2	Bulgaria PPE For (1) Radan KANEV Against (6) Alexander ALEXANDROV YORDANOV, Andrey KOVATCHEV, Andrey NOVAKOV, Asim ADEMOV, Emil RADEV, Eva MAYDELL 7	Lithuania PPE Against (4) Andrius KUBILIUS, Aušra SEIBUTYTĖ, Liudas MAŽYLIS, Rasa JUKNEVIČIENĖ 4	Croatia PPE Against (3) Karlo RESSLER, Tomislav SOKOL, Željana ZOVKO 3	Slovakia PPE For (2) Ivan ŠTEFANEC, Peter POLLÁK Against (1) Vladimír BILČÍK 3	Sweden PPE Against (3) Arba KOKALARI, Jörgen WARBORN, Tomas TOBÉ 3	Slovenia PPE Against (4) Franc BOGOVIČ, Ljudmila NOVAK, Milan ZVER, Romana TOMC 4	Ireland PPE Against (5) Colm MARKEY, Deirdre CLUNE, Frances FITZGERALD, Maria WALSH, Seán KELLY 5	Greece PPE Against (5) Anna-Michelle ASIMAKOPOULOU, Manolis KEFALOGIANNIS, Maria SPYRAKI, Stelios KYMPOUROPOULOS, Vangelis MEIMARAKIS 5	Italy PPE Against (9) Aldo PATRICIELLO, Francesca PEPPUCCI, Fulvio MARTUSCIELLO, Herbert DORFMANN, Isabella ADINOLFI, Lucia VUOLO, Massimiliano SALINI, Salvatore DE MEO, Stefania ZAMBELLI 9	Denmark PPE Against (1) Pernille WEISS 1	Netherlands PPE For (1) Anja HAGA Against (4) Antonius MANDERS, Esther DE LANGE, Jeroen LENAERS, Tom BERENDSEN 5	Belgium PPE Against (4) Benoît LUTGEN, Cindy FRANSSEN, Pascal ARIMONT, Tom VANDENKENDELAERE 4	Portugal PPE Against (5) Carlos COELHO, Cláudia MONTEIRO DE AGUIAR, José Manuel FERNANDES, Lídia PEREIRA, Maria da Graça CARVALHO 5	Romania PPE Against (10) Cristian-Silviu BUŞOI, Daniel BUDA, Eugen TOMAC, Gheorghe FALCĂ, Gheorghe-Vlad NISTOR, Iuliu WINKLER, Loránt VINCZE, Marian-Jean MARINESCU, Siegfried MUREŞAN, Traian BĂSESCU 10	Austria PPE Against (6) Alexander BERNHUBER, Angelika WINZIG, Christian SAGARTZ, Lukas MANDL, Othmar KARAS, Wolfram PIRCHNER 6	Spain PPE For (1) Leopoldo LÓPEZ GIL Against (10) Ana COLLADO JIMÉNEZ, Antonio LÓPEZ-ISTÚRIZ WHITE, Dolors MONTSERRAT, Francisco José MILLÁN MON, Isabel BENJUMEA BENJUMEA, José Manuel GARCÍA-MARGALLO Y MARFIL, Juan Ignacio ZOIDO ÁLVAREZ, Pablo ARIAS ECHEVERRÍA, Pilar del CASTILLO VERA, Rosa ESTARÀS FERRAGUT 11	France PPE Against (6) Anne SANDER, Arnaud DANJEAN, Brice HORTEFEUX, François-Xavier BELLAMY, Laurence SAILLIET, Nathalie COLIN-OESTERLÉ 6	Germany PPE For (2) Markus FERBER, Peter LIESE Against (25) Andreas SCHWAB, Angelika NIEBLER, Axel VOSS, Christian DOLESCHAL, Christine SCHNEIDER, Daniel CASPARY, David McALLISTER, Dennis RADTKE, Helmut GEUKING, Jens GIESEKE, Karolin BRAUNSBERGER-REINHOLD, Lena DÜPONT, Manfred WEBER, Markus PIEPER, Marlene MORTLER, Michael GAHLER, Monika HOHLMEIER, Niclas HERBST, Norbert LINS, Peter JAHR, Rainer WIELAND, Ralf SEEKATZ, Sabine VERHEYEN, Stefan BERGER, Sven SIMON 27

RC-B9-0453/2023 – After § 8 – Am 3 #

		PL	LV	EE	CY	FI	SI	MT	LU	BG	SK	SE	CZ	HU	LT	HR	IE	DK	BE	IT	NL	EL	RO	AT	PT	ES	FR	DE
	Total	44	7	7	4	9	8	5	5	12	12	17	20	16	9	11	12	13	20	62	25	16	21	17	17	54	63	79
ECR	61	Poland ECR For (22) Adam BIELAN, Andżelika Anna MOŻDŻANOWSKA, Anna FOTYGA, Anna ZALEWSKA, Beata KEMPA, Beata MAZUREK, Bogdan RZOŃCA, Dominik TARCZYŃSKI, Elżbieta KRUK, Elżbieta RAFALSKA, Grzegorz TOBISZOWSKI, Izabela-Helena KLOC, Jacek SARYUSZ-WOLSKI, Jadwiga WIŚNIEWSKA, Joachim Stanisław BRUDZIŃSKI, Joanna KOPCIŃSKA, Karol KARSKI, Kosma ZŁOTOWSKI, Patryk JAKI, Ryszard Antoni LEGUTKO, Witold Jan WASZCZYKOWSKI, Zdzisław KRASNODĘBSKI Against (1) Ryszard CZARNECKI 23	Latvia ECR For (1) Roberts ZĪLE 1			Finland ECR For (2) Pirkko RUOHONEN-LERNER, Teuvo HAKKARAINEN 2				Bulgaria ECR For (2) Andrey SLABAKOV, Angel DZHAMBAZKI 2	Slovakia ECR For (1) Eugen JURZYCA 1	Sweden ECR For (3) Charlie WEIMERS, Johan NISSINEN, Peter LUNDGREN 3	Czechia ECR For (4) Alexandr VONDRA, Evžen TOŠENOVSKÝ, Jan ZAHRADIL, Veronika VRECIONOVÁ 4			Croatia ECR Abstain (1) Ladislav ILČIĆ 1			Belgium ECR For (2) Geert BOURGEOIS, Johan VAN OVERTVELDT Abstain (1) Assita KANKO 3	Italy ECR For (9) Carlo FIDANZA, Denis NESCI, Elisabetta DE BLASIS, Giuseppe MILAZZO, Nicola PROCACCINI, Pietro FIOCCHI, Raffaele STANCANELLI, Sergio BERLATO, Vincenzo SOFO 9	Netherlands ECR For (2) Bert-Jan RUISSEN, Dorien ROOKMAKER Abstain (3) Michiel HOOGEVEEN, Rob ROOKEN, Robert ROOS 5	Greece ECR Against (1) Emmanouil FRAGKOS 1	Romania ECR For (1) Cristian TERHEŞ 1			Spain ECR For (4) Hermann TERTSCH, Jorge BUXADÉ VILLALBA, Margarita DE LA PISA CARRIÓN, Mazaly AGUILAR 4		Germany ECR For (1) Lars Patrick BERG 1
ID	48			Estonia ID For (1) Jaak MADISON 1									Czechia ID Against (1) Ivan DAVID 1					Denmark ID For (1) Anders VISTISEN 1	Belgium ID Abstain (3) Filip DE MAN, Gerolf ANNEMANS, Tom VANDENDRIESSCHE 3	Italy ID Abstain (17) Alessandro PANZA, Angelo CIOCCA, Anna BONFRISCO, Annalisa TARDINO, Danilo Oscar LANCINI, Elena LIZZI, Gianantonio DA RE, Gianna GANCIA, Marco CAMPOMENOSI, Maria Veronica ROSSI, Matteo GAZZINI, Paola GHIDONI, Paolo BORCHIA, Rosanna CONTE, Silvia SARDONE, Susanna CECCARDI, Valentino GRANT 17				Austria ID Against (3) Georg MAYER, Harald VILIMSKY, Roman HAIDER 3			France ID Against (14) André ROUGÉ, Aurélia BEIGNEUX, Catherine GRISET, Dominique BILDE, France JAMET, Gilles LEBRETON, Jean-Paul GARRAUD, Jordan BARDELLA, Marie DAUCHY, Mathilde ANDROUËT, Patricia CHAGNON, Philippe OLIVIER, Thierry MARIANI, Virginie JORON 14	Germany ID Against (8) Bernhard ZIMNIOK, Christine ANDERSON, Guido REIL, Gunnar BECK, Joachim KUHS, Markus BUCHHEIT, Nicolaus FEST, Sylvia LIMMER 8
The Left	30				Cyprus The Left Against (1) Giorgos GEORGIOU 1							Sweden The Left Against (1) Malin BJÖRK 1	Czechia The Left Against (1) Kateřina KONEČNÁ 1				Ireland The Left For (1) Chris MACMANUS Against (3) Clare DALY, Luke Ming FLANAGAN, Mick WALLACE 4	Denmark The Left Against (1) Nikolaj VILLUMSEN 1	Belgium The Left Against (1) Marc BOTENGA 1		Netherlands The Left Abstain (1) Anja HAZEKAMP 1	Greece The Left Against (3) Dimitrios PAPADIMOULIS, Konstantinos ARVANITIS, Petros KOKKALIS 3			Portugal The Left Against (3) José GUSMÃO, João PIMENTA LOPES, Sandra PEREIRA 3	Spain The Left Against (5) Eugenia RODRÍGUEZ PALOP, Idoia VILLANUEVA RUIZ, Manu PINEDA, Miguel URBÁN CRESPO, Sira REGO 5	France The Left Against (4) Anne-Sophie PELLETIER, Emmanuel MAUREL, Marina MESURE, Younous OMARJEE Abstain (2) Leila CHAIBI, Manon AUBRY 6	Germany The Left Against (3) Helmut SCHOLZ, Martin SCHIRDEWAN, Özlem DEMIREL 3
NI	39		Latvia NI Against (1) Tatjana ŽDANOKA 1								Slovakia NI Against (4) Katarína ROTH NEVEĎALOVÁ, Milan UHRÍK, Miroslav RADAČOVSKÝ, Monika BEŇOVÁ 4			Hungary NI Against (11) Andor DELI, Andrea BOCSKOR, Balázs HIDVÉGHI, Edina TÓTH, Enikő GYŐRI, Ernő SCHALLER-BAROSS, Kinga GÁL, László TRÓCSÁNYI, Lívia JÁRÓKA, Tamás DEUTSCH, Ádám KÓSA 11		Croatia NI Against (1) Ivan Vilibor SINČIĆ Abstain (1) Mislav KOLAKUŠIĆ 2			Belgium NI Against (1) Marc TARABELLA 1	Italy NI For (1) Mario FURORE Against (4) Andrea COZZOLINO, Dino GIARRUSSO, Francesca DONATO, Maria Angela DANZÌ Abstain (4) Fabio Massimo CASTALDO, Laura FERRARA, Sabrina PIGNEDOLI, Tiziana BEGHIN 9	Netherlands NI Against (1) Marcel de GRAAFF 1	Greece NI Against (1) Alexis GEORGOULIS Abstain (3) Eva KAILI, Kostas PAPADAKIS, Lefteris NIKOLAOU-ALAVANOS 4				Spain NI Abstain (3) Antoni COMÍN I OLIVERES, Carles PUIGDEMONT I CASAMAJÓ, Clara PONSATÍ OBIOLS 3	France NI Against (1) Hervé JUVIN 1	Germany NI Against (2) Jörg MEUTHEN, Martin BUSCHMANN 2
Verts/ALE	66	Poland Verts/ALE Against (1) Sylwia SPUREK 1				Finland Verts/ALE Against (3) Alviina ALAMETSÄ, Heidi HAUTALA, Ville NIINISTÖ 3						Sweden Verts/ALE Against (3) Alice KUHNKE, Jakop G. DALUNDE, Pär HOLMGREN 3	Czechia Verts/ALE Against (3) Marcel KOLAJA, Markéta GREGOROVÁ, Mikuláš PEKSA 3		Lithuania Verts/ALE Against (2) Bronis ROPĖ, Stasys JAKELIŪNAS 2		Ireland Verts/ALE Against (1) Ciarán CUFFE 1	Denmark Verts/ALE Against (2) Kira Marie PETER-HANSEN, Margrete AUKEN 2	Belgium Verts/ALE Against (3) Philippe LAMBERTS, Sara MATTHIEU, Saskia BRICMONT 3	Italy Verts/ALE Against (3) Ignazio CORRAO, Piernicola PEDICINI, Rosa D'AMATO 3	Netherlands Verts/ALE Against (3) Bas EICKHOUT, Kim VAN SPARRENTAK, Tineke STRIK 3			Austria Verts/ALE Against (3) Monika VANA, Sarah WIENER, Thomas WAITZ 3	Portugal Verts/ALE Against (1) Francisco GUERREIRO 1	Spain Verts/ALE Against (4) Ana MIRANDA, Diana RIBA I GINER, Ernest URTASUN, Jordi SOLÉ 4	France Verts/ALE Against (12) Benoît BITEAU, Caroline ROOSE, Claude GRUFFAT, Damien CARÊME, David CORMAND, François ALFONSI, Gwendoline DELBOS-CORFIELD, Karima DELLI, Lydie MASSARD, Marie TOUSSAINT, Michèle RIVASI, Mounir SATOURI 12	Germany Verts/ALE Against (22) Alexandra GEESE, Anna CAVAZZINI, Anna DEPARNAY-GRUNENBERG, Damian BOESELAGER, Daniel FREUND, Erik MARQUARDT, Hannah NEUMANN, Henrike HAHN, Jutta PAULUS, Katrin LANGENSIEPEN, Malte GALLÉE, Manuela RIPA, Martin HÄUSLING, Michael BLOSS, Nico SEMSROTT, Niklas NIENASS, Patrick BREYER, Pierrette HERZBERGER-FOFANA, Rasmus ANDRESEN, Sergey LAGODINSKY, Ska KELLER, Terry REINTKE 22
S&D	110	Poland S&D For (4) Marek BELKA, Marek Paweł BALT, Robert BIEDROŃ, Łukasz KOHUT Against (2) Bogusław LIBERADZKI, Leszek MILLER 6	Latvia S&D Against (1) Nils UŠAKOVS 1	Estonia S&D For (2) Marina KALJURAND, Sven MIKSER 2	Cyprus S&D Against (1) Demetris PAPADAKIS 1	Finland S&D Against (2) Eero HEINÄLUOMA, Miapetra KUMPULA-NATRI 2	Slovenia S&D For (1) Matjaž NEMEC Against (1) Milan BRGLEZ 2	Malta S&D Against (4) Alex AGIUS SALIBA, Alfred SANT, Cyrus ENGERER, Josianne CUTAJAR 4	Luxembourg S&D Against (1) Marc ANGEL 1		Slovakia S&D Against (1) Robert HAJŠEL 1	Sweden S&D Against (4) Carina OHLSSON, Evin INCIR, Heléne FRITZON, Ilan DE BASSO 4	Czechia S&D Against (1) Radka MAXOVÁ 1	Hungary S&D For (4) Attila ARA-KOVÁCS, Csaba MOLNÁR, Klára DOBREV, Sándor RÓNAI 4	Lithuania S&D Against (2) Juozas OLEKAS, Vilija BLINKEVIČIŪTĖ 2	Croatia S&D Against (4) Biljana BORZAN, Predrag Fred MATIĆ, Romana JERKOVIĆ, Tonino PICULA 4		Denmark S&D Against (3) Christel SCHALDEMOSE, Marianne VIND, Niels FUGLSANG 3	Belgium S&D Against (1) Kathleen VAN BREMPT 1	Italy S&D For (1) Brando BENIFEI Against (6) Achille VARIATI, Elisabetta GUALMINI, Massimiliano SMERIGLIO, Paolo DE CASTRO, Pietro BARTOLO, Pina PICIERNO Abstain (6) Alessandra MORETTI, Beatrice COVASSI, Daniela RONDINELLI, Irene TINAGLI, Mercedes BRESSO, Patrizia TOIA 13	Netherlands S&D Against (3) Agnes JONGERIUS, Mohammed CHAHIM, Thijs REUTEN 3	Greece S&D Against (1) Nikos PAPANDREOU 1	Romania S&D Against (3) Maria GRAPINI, Mihai TUDOSE, Rovana PLUMB Abstain (3) Adrian-Dragoş BENEA, Tudor CIUHODARU, Victor NEGRESCU 6	Austria S&D Against (5) Andreas SCHIEDER, Evelyn REGNER, Günther SIDL, Hannes HEIDE, Theresa BIELOWSKI 5	Portugal S&D Against (8) Carlos ZORRINHO, Isabel CARVALHAIS, Isabel SANTOS, João ALBUQUERQUE, Margarida MARQUES, Maria-Manuel LEITÃO-MARQUES, Pedro SILVA PEREIRA, Sara CERDAS 8	Spain S&D Against (18) Alicia HOMS GINEL, Clara AGUILERA, Cristina MAESTRE MARTÍN DE ALMAGRO, César LUENA, Domènec RUIZ DEVESA, Eider GARDIAZABAL RUBIAL, Ibán GARCÍA DEL BLANCO, Inma RODRÍGUEZ-PIÑERO, Iratxe GARCÍA PÉREZ, Isabel GARCÍA MUÑOZ, Javi LÓPEZ, Javier MORENO SÁNCHEZ, Jonás FERNÁNDEZ, Laura BALLARÍN CEREZA, Marcos ROS SEMPERE, Mónica Silvana GONZÁLEZ, Nacho SÁNCHEZ AMOR, Nicolás GONZÁLEZ CASARES 18	France S&D For (1) Pascal DURAND Against (6) Aurore LALUCQ, Christophe CLERGEAU, Nora MEBAREK, Pierre LARROUTUROU, Raphaël GLUCKSMANN, Sylvie GUILLAUME 7	Germany S&D Against (10) Bernd LANGE, Delara BURKHARDT, Jens GEIER, Karsten LUCKE, Matthias ECKE, Petra KAMMEREVERT, René REPASI, Thomas RUDNER, Tiemo WÖLKEN, Udo BULLMANN 10
Renew	84	Poland Renew Against (1) Róża THUN UND HOHENSTEIN 1	Latvia Renew For (1) Ivars IJABS 1	Estonia Renew Against (3) Andrus ANSIP, Jana TOOM, Urmas PAET 3		Finland Renew Against (1) Nils TORVALDS 1	Slovenia Renew Against (2) Irena JOVEVA, Klemen GROŠELJ 2		Luxembourg Renew Against (2) Charles GOERENS, Monica SEMEDO 2	Bulgaria Renew Against (3) Atidzhe ALIEVA-VELI, Ilhan KYUCHYUK, Iskra MIHAYLOVA 3	Slovakia Renew Against (3) Jozef MIHÁL, Lucia ĎURIŠ NICHOLSONOVÁ, Michal WIEZIK 3	Sweden Renew For (1) Karin KARLSBRO Against (2) Abir AL-SAHLANI, Emma WIESNER 3	Czechia Renew Against (5) Dita CHARANZOVÁ, Martin HLAVÁČEK, Martina DLABAJOVÁ, Ondřej KNOTEK, Ondřej KOVAŘÍK 5	Hungary Renew Against (1) Katalin CSEH 1	Lithuania Renew Abstain (1) Petras AUŠTREVIČIUS 1	Croatia Renew Against (1) Valter FLEGO 1	Ireland Renew Against (2) Barry ANDREWS, Billy KELLEHER 2	Denmark Renew Against (5) Asger CHRISTENSEN, Bergur Løkke RASMUSSEN, Karen MELCHIOR, Morten LØKKEGAARD, Morten PETERSEN 5	Belgium Renew Against (4) Frédérique RIES, Guy VERHOFSTADT, Hilde VAUTMANS, Olivier CHASTEL 4	Italy Renew Against (2) Giuseppe FERRANDINO, Marco ZULLO 2	Netherlands Renew For (1) Catharina RINZEMA Against (6) Bart GROOTHUIS, Caroline NAGTEGAAL, Jan HUITEMA, Malik AZMANI, Samira RAFAELA, Sophia IN 'T VELD 7	Greece Renew Against (1) Georgios KYRTSOS 1	Romania Renew Against (4) Dragoş PÎSLARU, Dragoş TUDORACHE, Ramona STRUGARIU, Vlad GHEORGHE 4			Spain Renew Against (9) Adrián VÁZQUEZ LÁZARA, Eva Maria POPTCHEVA, Izaskun BILBAO BARANDICA, Javier NART, Jordi CAÑAS, José Ramón BAUZÁ DÍAZ, Maite PAGAZAURTUNDÚA, María Soraya RODRÍGUEZ RAMOS, Susana SOLÍS PÉREZ 9	France Renew Against (17) Bernard GUETTA, Catherine AMALRIC, Christophe GRUDLER, Dominique RIQUET, Fabienne KELLER, Gilles BOYER, Ilana CICUREL, Irène TOLLERET, Jérémy DECERLE, Laurence FARRENG, Nathalie LOISEAU, Pierre KARLESKIND, Salima YENBOU, Sandro GOZI, Stéphane SÉJOURNÉ, Stéphanie YON-COURTIN, Valérie HAYER 17	Germany Renew Against (6) Andreas GLÜCK, Engin EROGLU, Jan-Christoph OETJEN, Moritz KÖRNER, Svenja HAHN, Ulrike MÜLLER 6
PPE	147	Poland PPE For (10) Adam JARUBAS, Andrzej HALICKI, Elżbieta Katarzyna ŁUKACIJEWSKA, Ewa KOPACZ, Jan OLBRYCHT, Janina OCHOJSKA, Jarosław KALINOWSKI, Magdalena ADAMOWICZ, Radosław SIKORSKI, Tomasz FRANKOWSKI Against (3) Danuta Maria HÜBNER, Jarosław DUDA, Jerzy BUZEK 13	Latvia PPE For (1) Dace MELBĀRDE Against (2) Inese VAIDERE, Sandra KALNIETE 3	Estonia PPE Against (1) Riho TERRAS 1	Cyprus PPE Against (2) Eleni STAVROU, Loucas FOURLAS 2	Finland PPE Against (1) Sirpa PIETIKÄINEN 1	Slovenia PPE Against (3) Franc BOGOVIČ, Ljudmila NOVAK, Romana TOMC Abstain (1) Milan ZVER 4	Malta PPE Against (1) David CASA 1	Luxembourg PPE Against (2) Isabel WISELER-LIMA, Martine KEMP 2	Bulgaria PPE For (1) Radan KANEV Against (6) Alexander ALEXANDROV YORDANOV, Andrey KOVATCHEV, Andrey NOVAKOV, Asim ADEMOV, Emil RADEV, Eva MAYDELL 7	Slovakia PPE For (1) Ivan ŠTEFANEC Against (1) Vladimír BILČÍK Abstain (1) Peter POLLÁK 3	Sweden PPE Against (1) Tomas TOBÉ Abstain (2) Arba KOKALARI, Jörgen WARBORN 3	Czechia PPE For (1) Jiří POSPÍŠIL Against (2) Luděk NIEDERMAYER, Michaela ŠOJDROVÁ Abstain (2) Stanislav POLČÁK, Tomáš ZDECHOVSKÝ 5		Lithuania PPE Against (4) Andrius KUBILIUS, Aušra SEIBUTYTĖ, Liudas MAŽYLIS, Rasa JUKNEVIČIENĖ 4	Croatia PPE Against (3) Karlo RESSLER, Tomislav SOKOL, Željana ZOVKO 3	Ireland PPE Against (5) Colm MARKEY, Deirdre CLUNE, Frances FITZGERALD, Maria WALSH, Seán KELLY 5	Denmark PPE Against (1) Pernille WEISS 1	Belgium PPE Against (4) Benoît LUTGEN, Cindy FRANSSEN, Pascal ARIMONT, Tom VANDENKENDELAERE 4	Italy PPE Against (9) Aldo PATRICIELLO, Francesca PEPPUCCI, Fulvio MARTUSCIELLO, Herbert DORFMANN, Isabella ADINOLFI, Lucia VUOLO, Massimiliano SALINI, Salvatore DE MEO, Stefania ZAMBELLI 9	Netherlands PPE For (1) Anja HAGA Against (4) Antonius MANDERS, Esther DE LANGE, Jeroen LENAERS, Tom BERENDSEN 5	Greece PPE Against (6) Anna-Michelle ASIMAKOPOULOU, Manolis KEFALOGIANNIS, Maria SPYRAKI, Stelios KYMPOUROPOULOS, Theodoros ZAGORAKIS, Vangelis MEIMARAKIS 6	Romania PPE Against (10) Cristian-Silviu BUŞOI, Daniel BUDA, Eugen TOMAC, Gheorghe FALCĂ, Gheorghe-Vlad NISTOR, Iuliu WINKLER, Loránt VINCZE, Marian-Jean MARINESCU, Siegfried MUREŞAN, Traian BĂSESCU 10	Austria PPE Against (6) Alexander BERNHUBER, Angelika WINZIG, Christian SAGARTZ, Lukas MANDL, Othmar KARAS, Wolfram PIRCHNER 6	Portugal PPE Against (5) Carlos COELHO, Cláudia MONTEIRO DE AGUIAR, José Manuel FERNANDES, Lídia PEREIRA, Maria da Graça CARVALHO 5	Spain PPE Against (11) Ana COLLADO JIMÉNEZ, Antonio LÓPEZ-ISTÚRIZ WHITE, Dolors MONTSERRAT, Francisco José MILLÁN MON, Isabel BENJUMEA BENJUMEA, Javier ZARZALEJOS, Juan Ignacio ZOIDO ÁLVAREZ, Leopoldo LÓPEZ GIL, Pablo ARIAS ECHEVERRÍA, Pilar del CASTILLO VERA, Rosa ESTARÀS FERRAGUT 11	France PPE Against (6) Anne SANDER, Arnaud DANJEAN, Brice HORTEFEUX, François-Xavier BELLAMY, Laurence SAILLIET, Nathalie COLIN-OESTERLÉ 6	Germany PPE Against (27) Andreas SCHWAB, Angelika NIEBLER, Axel VOSS, Christian DOLESCHAL, Christian EHLER, Christine SCHNEIDER, Daniel CASPARY, David McALLISTER, Dennis RADTKE, Helmut GEUKING, Jens GIESEKE, Karolin BRAUNSBERGER-REINHOLD, Lena DÜPONT, Manfred WEBER, Markus FERBER, Markus PIEPER, Marlene MORTLER, Michael GAHLER, Monika HOHLMEIER, Niclas HERBST, Norbert LINS, Peter JAHR, Peter LIESE, Rainer WIELAND, Ralf SEEKATZ, Sabine VERHEYEN, Sven SIMON 27

RC-B9-0453/2023 – After § 18 – Am 4 #

		IT	ES	PL	DE	RO	NL	BE	BG	PT	SE	CZ	SK	HR	AT	SI	EE	DK	LT	HU	LV	LU	FI	MT	IE	CY	EL	FR
	Total	63	55	47	80	21	24	21	12	17	18	20	13	11	17	8	7	13	9	17	7	5	10	5	12	4	14	64
PPE	150	Italy PPE For (8) Aldo PATRICIELLO, Francesca PEPPUCCI, Fulvio MARTUSCIELLO, Herbert DORFMANN, Lucia VUOLO, Massimiliano SALINI, Salvatore DE MEO, Stefania ZAMBELLI Abstain (1) Isabella ADINOLFI 9	Spain PPE For (12) Ana COLLADO JIMÉNEZ, Antonio LÓPEZ-ISTÚRIZ WHITE, Dolors MONTSERRAT, Francisco José MILLÁN MON, Isabel BENJUMEA BENJUMEA, Javier ZARZALEJOS, José Manuel GARCÍA-MARGALLO Y MARFIL, Juan Ignacio ZOIDO ÁLVAREZ, Leopoldo LÓPEZ GIL, Pablo ARIAS ECHEVERRÍA, Pilar del CASTILLO VERA, Rosa ESTARÀS FERRAGUT 12	Poland PPE For (13) Adam JARUBAS, Andrzej HALICKI, Danuta Maria HÜBNER, Elżbieta Katarzyna ŁUKACIJEWSKA, Ewa KOPACZ, Jan OLBRYCHT, Janina OCHOJSKA, Jarosław DUDA, Jarosław KALINOWSKI, Jerzy BUZEK, Magdalena ADAMOWICZ, Radosław SIKORSKI, Tomasz FRANKOWSKI Abstain (1) Janusz LEWANDOWSKI 14	Germany PPE For (28) Andreas SCHWAB, Angelika NIEBLER, Axel VOSS, Christian DOLESCHAL, Christian EHLER, Christine SCHNEIDER, Daniel CASPARY, David McALLISTER, Dennis RADTKE, Helmut GEUKING, Jens GIESEKE, Karolin BRAUNSBERGER-REINHOLD, Lena DÜPONT, Manfred WEBER, Markus FERBER, Markus PIEPER, Marlene MORTLER, Michael GAHLER, Monika HOHLMEIER, Niclas HERBST, Norbert LINS, Peter JAHR, Peter LIESE, Rainer WIELAND, Ralf SEEKATZ, Sabine VERHEYEN, Stefan BERGER, Sven SIMON 28	Romania PPE For (10) Cristian-Silviu BUŞOI, Daniel BUDA, Eugen TOMAC, Gheorghe FALCĂ, Gheorghe-Vlad NISTOR, Iuliu WINKLER, Loránt VINCZE, Marian-Jean MARINESCU, Siegfried MUREŞAN, Traian BĂSESCU 10	Netherlands PPE For (5) Anja HAGA, Antonius MANDERS, Esther DE LANGE, Jeroen LENAERS, Tom BERENDSEN 5	Belgium PPE For (4) Benoît LUTGEN, Cindy FRANSSEN, Pascal ARIMONT, Tom VANDENKENDELAERE 4	Bulgaria PPE For (7) Alexander ALEXANDROV YORDANOV, Andrey KOVATCHEV, Andrey NOVAKOV, Asim ADEMOV, Emil RADEV, Eva MAYDELL, Radan KANEV 7	Portugal PPE For (5) Carlos COELHO, Cláudia MONTEIRO DE AGUIAR, José Manuel FERNANDES, Lídia PEREIRA, Maria da Graça CARVALHO 5	Sweden PPE For (4) Arba KOKALARI, Jörgen WARBORN, Sara SKYTTEDAL, Tomas TOBÉ 4	Czechia PPE For (5) Jiří POSPÍŠIL, Luděk NIEDERMAYER, Michaela ŠOJDROVÁ, Stanislav POLČÁK, Tomáš ZDECHOVSKÝ 5	Slovakia PPE For (3) Ivan ŠTEFANEC, Peter POLLÁK, Vladimír BILČÍK 3	Croatia PPE For (3) Karlo RESSLER, Tomislav SOKOL, Željana ZOVKO 3	Austria PPE For (6) Alexander BERNHUBER, Angelika WINZIG, Christian SAGARTZ, Lukas MANDL, Othmar KARAS, Wolfram PIRCHNER 6	Slovenia PPE For (4) Franc BOGOVIČ, Ljudmila NOVAK, Milan ZVER, Romana TOMC 4	Estonia PPE For (1) Riho TERRAS 1	Denmark PPE For (1) Pernille WEISS 1	Lithuania PPE For (4) Andrius KUBILIUS, Aušra SEIBUTYTĖ, Liudas MAŽYLIS, Rasa JUKNEVIČIENĖ 4		Latvia PPE For (3) Dace MELBĀRDE, Inese VAIDERE, Sandra KALNIETE 3	Luxembourg PPE For (2) Isabel WISELER-LIMA, Martine KEMP 2	Finland PPE Against (1) Sirpa PIETIKÄINEN 1	Malta PPE For (1) David CASA 1	Ireland PPE For (5) Colm MARKEY, Deirdre CLUNE, Frances FITZGERALD, Maria WALSH, Seán KELLY 5	Cyprus PPE For (2) Eleni STAVROU, Loucas FOURLAS 2	Greece PPE For (4) Anna-Michelle ASIMAKOPOULOU, Stelios KYMPOUROPOULOS, Theodoros ZAGORAKIS, Vangelis MEIMARAKIS Against (1) Maria SPYRAKI 5	France PPE For (6) Anne SANDER, Arnaud DANJEAN, Brice HORTEFEUX, François-Xavier BELLAMY, Laurence SAILLIET, Nathalie COLIN-OESTERLÉ 6
S&D	111	Italy S&D For (12) Achille VARIATI, Alessandra MORETTI, Beatrice COVASSI, Brando BENIFEI, Daniela RONDINELLI, Elisabetta GUALMINI, Irene TINAGLI, Mercedes BRESSO, Paolo DE CASTRO, Patrizia TOIA, Pietro BARTOLO, Pina PICIERNO 12	Spain S&D For (18) Alicia HOMS GINEL, Clara AGUILERA, Cristina MAESTRE MARTÍN DE ALMAGRO, César LUENA, Domènec RUIZ DEVESA, Eider GARDIAZABAL RUBIAL, Ibán GARCÍA DEL BLANCO, Inma RODRÍGUEZ-PIÑERO, Iratxe GARCÍA PÉREZ, Isabel GARCÍA MUÑOZ, Javi LÓPEZ, Javier MORENO SÁNCHEZ, Jonás FERNÁNDEZ, Laura BALLARÍN CEREZA, Marcos ROS SEMPERE, Mónica Silvana GONZÁLEZ, Nacho SÁNCHEZ AMOR, Nicolás GONZÁLEZ CASARES 18	Poland S&D For (5) Bogusław LIBERADZKI, Marek BELKA, Marek Paweł BALT, Robert BIEDROŃ, Łukasz KOHUT Abstain (1) Leszek MILLER 6	Germany S&D For (10) Bernd LANGE, Delara BURKHARDT, Jens GEIER, Karsten LUCKE, Matthias ECKE, Petra KAMMEREVERT, René REPASI, Thomas RUDNER, Tiemo WÖLKEN, Udo BULLMANN 10	Romania S&D For (6) Adrian-Dragoş BENEA, Maria GRAPINI, Mihai TUDOSE, Rovana PLUMB, Tudor CIUHODARU, Victor NEGRESCU 6	Netherlands S&D For (3) Agnes JONGERIUS, Mohammed CHAHIM, Thijs REUTEN 3	Belgium S&D For (2) Kathleen VAN BREMPT, Maria ARENA 2		Portugal S&D For (8) Carlos ZORRINHO, Isabel CARVALHAIS, Isabel SANTOS, João ALBUQUERQUE, Margarida MARQUES, Maria-Manuel LEITÃO-MARQUES, Pedro SILVA PEREIRA, Sara CERDAS 8	Sweden S&D For (4) Carina OHLSSON, Evin INCIR, Heléne FRITZON, Ilan DE BASSO 4	Czechia S&D For (1) Radka MAXOVÁ 1	Slovakia S&D For (1) Robert HAJŠEL 1	Croatia S&D For (4) Biljana BORZAN, Predrag Fred MATIĆ, Romana JERKOVIĆ, Tonino PICULA 4	Austria S&D For (5) Andreas SCHIEDER, Evelyn REGNER, Günther SIDL, Hannes HEIDE, Theresa BIELOWSKI 5	Slovenia S&D For (2) Matjaž NEMEC, Milan BRGLEZ 2	Estonia S&D For (2) Marina KALJURAND, Sven MIKSER 2	Denmark S&D For (3) Christel SCHALDEMOSE, Marianne VIND, Niels FUGLSANG 3	Lithuania S&D For (2) Juozas OLEKAS, Vilija BLINKEVIČIŪTĖ 2	Hungary S&D For (5) Attila ARA-KOVÁCS, Csaba MOLNÁR, István UJHELYI, Klára DOBREV, Sándor RÓNAI 5	Latvia S&D For (1) Nils UŠAKOVS 1	Luxembourg S&D For (1) Marc ANGEL 1	Finland S&D For (2) Eero HEINÄLUOMA, Miapetra KUMPULA-NATRI 2	Malta S&D For (3) Alex AGIUS SALIBA, Cyrus ENGERER, Josianne CUTAJAR Abstain (1) Alfred SANT 4		Cyprus S&D For (1) Demetris PAPADAKIS 1	Greece S&D For (1) Nikos PAPANDREOU 1	France S&D For (7) Aurore LALUCQ, Christophe CLERGEAU, Nora MEBAREK, Pascal DURAND, Pierre LARROUTUROU, Raphaël GLUCKSMANN, Sylvie GUILLAUME 7
Renew	86	Italy Renew For (2) Giuseppe FERRANDINO, Marco ZULLO 2	Spain Renew For (9) Adrián VÁZQUEZ LÁZARA, Eva Maria POPTCHEVA, Izaskun BILBAO BARANDICA, Javier NART, Jordi CAÑAS, José Ramón BAUZÁ DÍAZ, Maite PAGAZAURTUNDÚA, María Soraya RODRÍGUEZ RAMOS, Susana SOLÍS PÉREZ 9	Poland Renew For (1) Róża THUN UND HOHENSTEIN 1	Germany Renew For (6) Andreas GLÜCK, Engin EROGLU, Jan-Christoph OETJEN, Moritz KÖRNER, Svenja HAHN, Ulrike MÜLLER 6	Romania Renew For (4) Dragoş PÎSLARU, Dragoş TUDORACHE, Ramona STRUGARIU, Vlad GHEORGHE 4	Netherlands Renew For (7) Bart GROOTHUIS, Caroline NAGTEGAAL, Catharina RINZEMA, Jan HUITEMA, Malik AZMANI, Samira RAFAELA, Sophia IN 'T VELD 7	Belgium Renew For (4) Frédérique RIES, Guy VERHOFSTADT, Hilde VAUTMANS, Olivier CHASTEL 4	Bulgaria Renew For (3) Atidzhe ALIEVA-VELI, Ilhan KYUCHYUK, Iskra MIHAYLOVA 3		Sweden Renew For (3) Abir AL-SAHLANI, Emma WIESNER, Karin KARLSBRO 3	Czechia Renew For (5) Dita CHARANZOVÁ, Martin HLAVÁČEK, Martina DLABAJOVÁ, Ondřej KNOTEK, Ondřej KOVAŘÍK 5	Slovakia Renew For (4) Jozef MIHÁL, Lucia ĎURIŠ NICHOLSONOVÁ, Martin HOJSÍK, Michal WIEZIK 4	Croatia Renew For (1) Valter FLEGO 1		Slovenia Renew For (2) Irena JOVEVA, Klemen GROŠELJ 2	Estonia Renew For (3) Andrus ANSIP, Jana TOOM, Urmas PAET 3	Denmark Renew For (5) Asger CHRISTENSEN, Bergur Løkke RASMUSSEN, Karen MELCHIOR, Morten LØKKEGAARD, Morten PETERSEN 5	Lithuania Renew For (1) Petras AUŠTREVIČIUS 1	Hungary Renew For (1) Katalin CSEH 1	Latvia Renew For (1) Ivars IJABS 1	Luxembourg Renew For (2) Charles GOERENS, Monica SEMEDO 2	Finland Renew For (2) Mauri PEKKARINEN, Nils TORVALDS 2		Ireland Renew For (2) Barry ANDREWS, Billy KELLEHER 2		Greece Renew For (1) Georgios KYRTSOS 1	France Renew For (17) Bernard GUETTA, Catherine AMALRIC, Christophe GRUDLER, Dominique RIQUET, Fabienne KELLER, Gilles BOYER, Ilana CICUREL, Irène TOLLERET, Jérémy DECERLE, Laurence FARRENG, Nathalie LOISEAU, Pascal CANFIN, Salima YENBOU, Sandro GOZI, Stéphane SÉJOURNÉ, Stéphanie YON-COURTIN, Valérie HAYER 17
ECR	63	Italy ECR For (10) Carlo FIDANZA, Chiara GEMMA, Denis NESCI, Elisabetta DE BLASIS, Giuseppe MILAZZO, Nicola PROCACCINI, Pietro FIOCCHI, Raffaele STANCANELLI, Sergio BERLATO, Vincenzo SOFO 10	Spain ECR For (4) Hermann TERTSCH, Jorge BUXADÉ VILLALBA, Margarita DE LA PISA CARRIÓN, Mazaly AGUILAR 4	Poland ECR For (24) Adam BIELAN, Andżelika Anna MOŻDŻANOWSKA, Anna FOTYGA, Anna ZALEWSKA, Beata KEMPA, Beata MAZUREK, Beata SZYDŁO, Bogdan RZOŃCA, Dominik TARCZYŃSKI, Elżbieta KRUK, Elżbieta RAFALSKA, Grzegorz TOBISZOWSKI, Izabela-Helena KLOC, Jacek SARYUSZ-WOLSKI, Jadwiga WIŚNIEWSKA, Joachim Stanisław BRUDZIŃSKI, Joanna KOPCIŃSKA, Karol KARSKI, Kosma ZŁOTOWSKI, Krzysztof JURGIEL, Patryk JAKI, Ryszard Antoni LEGUTKO, Witold Jan WASZCZYKOWSKI, Zdzisław KRASNODĘBSKI Against (1) Ryszard CZARNECKI 25	Germany ECR For (1) Lars Patrick BERG 1	Romania ECR For (1) Cristian TERHEŞ 1	Netherlands ECR For (4) Bert-Jan RUISSEN, Dorien ROOKMAKER, Michiel HOOGEVEEN, Robert ROOS 4	Belgium ECR For (3) Assita KANKO, Geert BOURGEOIS, Johan VAN OVERTVELDT 3	Bulgaria ECR For (2) Andrey SLABAKOV, Angel DZHAMBAZKI 2		Sweden ECR For (3) Charlie WEIMERS, Johan NISSINEN, Peter LUNDGREN 3	Czechia ECR For (4) Alexandr VONDRA, Evžen TOŠENOVSKÝ, Jan ZAHRADIL, Veronika VRECIONOVÁ 4	Slovakia ECR For (1) Eugen JURZYCA 1	Croatia ECR For (1) Ladislav ILČIĆ 1							Latvia ECR For (1) Roberts ZĪLE 1		Finland ECR For (2) Pirkko RUOHONEN-LERNER, Teuvo HAKKARAINEN 2				Greece ECR Against (1) Emmanouil FRAGKOS 1
ID	50	Italy ID For (17) Alessandro PANZA, Angelo CIOCCA, Anna BONFRISCO, Annalisa TARDINO, Antonio Maria RINALDI, Danilo Oscar LANCINI, Elena LIZZI, Gianantonio DA RE, Gianna GANCIA, Marco CAMPOMENOSI, Maria Veronica ROSSI, Paola GHIDONI, Paolo BORCHIA, Rosanna CONTE, Silvia SARDONE, Susanna CECCARDI, Valentino GRANT Abstain (1) Matteo GAZZINI 18			Germany ID Abstain (8) Bernhard ZIMNIOK, Christine ANDERSON, Guido REIL, Gunnar BECK, Joachim KUHS, Markus BUCHHEIT, Nicolaus FEST, Sylvia LIMMER 8			Belgium ID For (3) Filip DE MAN, Gerolf ANNEMANS, Tom VANDENDRIESSCHE 3				Czechia ID Against (1) Ivan DAVID 1			Austria ID Abstain (3) Georg MAYER, Harald VILIMSKY, Roman HAIDER 3		Estonia ID For (1) Jaak MADISON 1	Denmark ID For (1) Anders VISTISEN 1										France ID Against (15) André ROUGÉ, Annika BRUNA, Aurélia BEIGNEUX, Catherine GRISET, Dominique BILDE, France JAMET, Gilles LEBRETON, Jean-Paul GARRAUD, Jordan BARDELLA, Marie DAUCHY, Mathilde ANDROUËT, Patricia CHAGNON, Philippe OLIVIER, Thierry MARIANI, Virginie JORON 15
NI	39	Italy NI For (7) Dino GIARRUSSO, Fabio Massimo CASTALDO, Laura FERRARA, Maria Angela DANZÌ, Mario FURORE, Sabrina PIGNEDOLI, Tiziana BEGHIN Against (2) Andrea COZZOLINO, Francesca DONATO 9	Spain NI For (3) Antoni COMÍN I OLIVERES, Carles PUIGDEMONT I CASAMAJÓ, Clara PONSATÍ OBIOLS 3		Germany NI For (1) Jörg MEUTHEN Against (1) Martin BUSCHMANN 2		Netherlands NI Against (1) Marcel de GRAAFF 1	Belgium NI For (1) Marc TARABELLA 1					Slovakia NI For (2) Katarína ROTH NEVEĎALOVÁ, Monika BEŇOVÁ Against (2) Milan UHRÍK, Miroslav RADAČOVSKÝ 4	Croatia NI Against (1) Ivan Vilibor SINČIĆ Abstain (1) Mislav KOLAKUŠIĆ 2						Hungary NI Abstain (11) Andor DELI, Andrea BOCSKOR, Balázs HIDVÉGHI, Edina TÓTH, Enikő GYŐRI, Ernő SCHALLER-BAROSS, Kinga GÁL, László TRÓCSÁNYI, Lívia JÁRÓKA, Tamás DEUTSCH, Ádám KÓSA 11	Latvia NI Against (1) Tatjana ŽDANOKA 1						Greece NI Against (1) Alexis GEORGOULIS Abstain (3) Eva KAILI, Kostas PAPADAKIS, Lefteris NIKOLAOU-ALAVANOS 4	France NI Against (1) Hervé JUVIN 1
The Left	29		Spain The Left For (3) Eugenia RODRÍGUEZ PALOP, Idoia VILLANUEVA RUIZ, Miguel URBÁN CRESPO Against (2) Manu PINEDA, Sira REGO 5		Germany The Left For (1) Özlem DEMIREL Against (2) Helmut SCHOLZ, Martin SCHIRDEWAN 3		Netherlands The Left For (1) Anja HAZEKAMP 1	Belgium The Left Against (1) Marc BOTENGA 1		Portugal The Left For (1) José GUSMÃO Against (2) João PIMENTA LOPES, Sandra PEREIRA 3	Sweden The Left Against (1) Malin BJÖRK 1	Czechia The Left Against (1) Kateřina KONEČNÁ 1						Denmark The Left Against (1) Nikolaj VILLUMSEN 1							Ireland The Left For (1) Chris MACMANUS Against (3) Clare DALY, Luke Ming FLANAGAN, Mick WALLACE 4	Cyprus The Left Against (1) Giorgos GEORGIOU 1	Greece The Left Against (2) Dimitrios PAPADIMOULIS, Petros KOKKALIS 2	France The Left Against (6) Anne-Sophie PELLETIER, Emmanuel MAUREL, Leila CHAIBI, Manon AUBRY, Marina MESURE, Younous OMARJEE 6
Verts/ALE	66	Italy Verts/ALE Against (3) Ignazio CORRAO, Piernicola PEDICINI, Rosa D'AMATO 3	Spain Verts/ALE Against (4) Ana MIRANDA, Diana RIBA I GINER, Ernest URTASUN, Jordi SOLÉ 4	Poland Verts/ALE Against (1) Sylwia SPUREK 1	Germany Verts/ALE Against (22) Alexandra GEESE, Anna CAVAZZINI, Anna DEPARNAY-GRUNENBERG, Damian BOESELAGER, Daniel FREUND, Erik MARQUARDT, Hannah NEUMANN, Henrike HAHN, Jutta PAULUS, Katrin LANGENSIEPEN, Malte GALLÉE, Manuela RIPA, Martin HÄUSLING, Michael BLOSS, Nico SEMSROTT, Niklas NIENASS, Patrick BREYER, Pierrette HERZBERGER-FOFANA, Rasmus ANDRESEN, Sergey LAGODINSKY, Ska KELLER, Terry REINTKE 22		Netherlands Verts/ALE Against (3) Bas EICKHOUT, Kim VAN SPARRENTAK, Tineke STRIK 3	Belgium Verts/ALE Against (3) Philippe LAMBERTS, Sara MATTHIEU, Saskia BRICMONT 3		Portugal Verts/ALE Against (1) Francisco GUERREIRO 1	Sweden Verts/ALE Against (3) Alice KUHNKE, Jakop G. DALUNDE, Pär HOLMGREN 3	Czechia Verts/ALE Against (3) Marcel KOLAJA, Markéta GREGOROVÁ, Mikuláš PEKSA 3			Austria Verts/ALE Against (3) Monika VANA, Sarah WIENER, Thomas WAITZ 3			Denmark Verts/ALE Against (2) Kira Marie PETER-HANSEN, Margrete AUKEN 2	Lithuania Verts/ALE For (1) Bronis ROPĖ Against (1) Stasys JAKELIŪNAS 2				Finland Verts/ALE For (1) Alviina ALAMETSÄ Against (2) Heidi HAUTALA, Ville NIINISTÖ 3		Ireland Verts/ALE Against (1) Ciarán CUFFE 1			France Verts/ALE For (1) David CORMAND Against (11) Benoît BITEAU, Caroline ROOSE, Claude GRUFFAT, Damien CARÊME, François ALFONSI, Gwendoline DELBOS-CORFIELD, Karima DELLI, Lydie MASSARD, Marie TOUSSAINT, Michèle RIVASI, Mounir SATOURI 12

RC-B9-0453/2023 – After recital L – Am 1 #

		PL	HU	LV	EE	BG	FI	SE	CY	MT	LU	HR	CZ	LT	SI	DK	IE	SK	BE	EL	IT	RO	NL	AT	PT	ES	FR	DE
	Total	44	17	7	7	12	10	17	4	5	5	11	20	9	8	13	12	13	21	15	61	21	25	17	17	55	63	79
ECR	62	Poland ECR For (24) Adam BIELAN, Andżelika Anna MOŻDŻANOWSKA, Anna FOTYGA, Anna ZALEWSKA, Beata KEMPA, Beata MAZUREK, Beata SZYDŁO, Bogdan RZOŃCA, Dominik TARCZYŃSKI, Elżbieta KRUK, Elżbieta RAFALSKA, Grzegorz TOBISZOWSKI, Izabela-Helena KLOC, Jacek SARYUSZ-WOLSKI, Jadwiga WIŚNIEWSKA, Joachim Stanisław BRUDZIŃSKI, Joanna KOPCIŃSKA, Karol KARSKI, Kosma ZŁOTOWSKI, Krzysztof JURGIEL, Ryszard Antoni LEGUTKO, Ryszard CZARNECKI, Witold Jan WASZCZYKOWSKI, Zdzisław KRASNODĘBSKI 24		Latvia ECR For (1) Roberts ZĪLE 1		Bulgaria ECR For (2) Andrey SLABAKOV, Angel DZHAMBAZKI 2	Finland ECR For (2) Pirkko RUOHONEN-LERNER, Teuvo HAKKARAINEN 2	Sweden ECR For (3) Charlie WEIMERS, Johan NISSINEN, Peter LUNDGREN 3				Croatia ECR For (1) Ladislav ILČIĆ 1	Czechia ECR For (4) Alexandr VONDRA, Evžen TOŠENOVSKÝ, Jan ZAHRADIL, Veronika VRECIONOVÁ 4					Slovakia ECR For (1) Eugen JURZYCA 1	Belgium ECR For (3) Assita KANKO, Geert BOURGEOIS, Johan VAN OVERTVELDT 3	Greece ECR Abstain (1) Emmanouil FRAGKOS 1	Italy ECR For (9) Carlo FIDANZA, Chiara GEMMA, Denis NESCI, Elisabetta DE BLASIS, Giuseppe MILAZZO, Nicola PROCACCINI, Pietro FIOCCHI, Sergio BERLATO, Vincenzo SOFO 9	Romania ECR For (1) Cristian TERHEŞ 1	Netherlands ECR For (1) Dorien ROOKMAKER Abstain (4) Bert-Jan RUISSEN, Michiel HOOGEVEEN, Rob ROOKEN, Robert ROOS 5			Spain ECR For (4) Hermann TERTSCH, Jorge BUXADÉ VILLALBA, Margarita DE LA PISA CARRIÓN, Mazaly AGUILAR 4		Germany ECR For (1) Lars Patrick BERG 1
The Left	28							Sweden The Left Against (1) Malin BJÖRK 1	Cyprus The Left Against (1) Giorgos GEORGIOU 1				Czechia The Left Against (1) Kateřina KONEČNÁ 1			Denmark The Left Against (1) Nikolaj VILLUMSEN 1	Ireland The Left For (1) Chris MACMANUS Against (2) Clare DALY, Mick WALLACE Abstain (1) Luke Ming FLANAGAN 4		Belgium The Left Against (1) Marc BOTENGA 1	Greece The Left Against (2) Dimitrios PAPADIMOULIS, Petros KOKKALIS 2			Netherlands The Left For (1) Anja HAZEKAMP 1		Portugal The Left Against (3) José GUSMÃO, João PIMENTA LOPES, Sandra PEREIRA 3	Spain The Left Against (5) Eugenia RODRÍGUEZ PALOP, Idoia VILLANUEVA RUIZ, Manu PINEDA, Miguel URBÁN CRESPO, Sira REGO 5	France The Left Abstain (5) Anne-Sophie PELLETIER, Emmanuel MAUREL, Leila CHAIBI, Marina MESURE, Younous OMARJEE 5	Germany The Left Against (3) Helmut SCHOLZ, Martin SCHIRDEWAN, Özlem DEMIREL 3
NI	39		Hungary NI Abstain (11) Andor DELI, Andrea BOCSKOR, Balázs HIDVÉGHI, Edina TÓTH, Enikő GYŐRI, Ernő SCHALLER-BAROSS, Kinga GÁL, László TRÓCSÁNYI, Lívia JÁRÓKA, Tamás DEUTSCH, Ádám KÓSA 11	Latvia NI Against (1) Tatjana ŽDANOKA 1								Croatia NI Against (1) Ivan Vilibor SINČIĆ Abstain (1) Mislav KOLAKUŠIĆ 2						Slovakia NI Against (4) Katarína ROTH NEVEĎALOVÁ, Milan UHRÍK, Miroslav RADAČOVSKÝ, Monika BEŇOVÁ 4	Belgium NI Against (1) Marc TARABELLA 1	Greece NI Against (2) Alexis GEORGOULIS, Eva KAILI Abstain (2) Kostas PAPADAKIS, Lefteris NIKOLAOU-ALAVANOS 4	Italy NI Against (3) Andrea COZZOLINO, Dino GIARRUSSO, Francesca DONATO Abstain (6) Fabio Massimo CASTALDO, Laura FERRARA, Maria Angela DANZÌ, Mario FURORE, Sabrina PIGNEDOLI, Tiziana BEGHIN 9		Netherlands NI Against (1) Marcel de GRAAFF 1			Spain NI Against (3) Antoni COMÍN I OLIVERES, Carles PUIGDEMONT I CASAMAJÓ, Clara PONSATÍ OBIOLS 3	France NI Against (1) Hervé JUVIN 1	Germany NI Against (2) Jörg MEUTHEN, Martin BUSCHMANN 2
ID	50				Estonia ID For (1) Jaak MADISON 1								Czechia ID Against (1) Ivan DAVID 1			Denmark ID For (1) Anders VISTISEN 1			Belgium ID Abstain (3) Filip DE MAN, Gerolf ANNEMANS, Tom VANDENDRIESSCHE 3		Italy ID Abstain (18) Alessandro PANZA, Angelo CIOCCA, Anna BONFRISCO, Annalisa TARDINO, Antonio Maria RINALDI, Danilo Oscar LANCINI, Elena LIZZI, Gianantonio DA RE, Gianna GANCIA, Marco CAMPOMENOSI, Maria Veronica ROSSI, Matteo GAZZINI, Paola GHIDONI, Paolo BORCHIA, Rosanna CONTE, Silvia SARDONE, Susanna CECCARDI, Valentino GRANT 18			Austria ID Against (3) Georg MAYER, Harald VILIMSKY, Roman HAIDER 3			France ID Against (15) André ROUGÉ, Annika BRUNA, Aurélia BEIGNEUX, Catherine GRISET, Dominique BILDE, France JAMET, Gilles LEBRETON, Jean-Paul GARRAUD, Jordan BARDELLA, Marie DAUCHY, Mathilde ANDROUËT, Patricia CHAGNON, Philippe OLIVIER, Thierry MARIANI, Virginie JORON 15	Germany ID Against (8) Bernhard ZIMNIOK, Christine ANDERSON, Guido REIL, Gunnar BECK, Joachim KUHS, Markus BUCHHEIT, Nicolaus FEST, Sylvia LIMMER 8
Verts/ALE	66	Poland Verts/ALE Against (1) Sylwia SPUREK 1					Finland Verts/ALE Against (3) Alviina ALAMETSÄ, Heidi HAUTALA, Ville NIINISTÖ 3	Sweden Verts/ALE Against (3) Alice KUHNKE, Jakop G. DALUNDE, Pär HOLMGREN 3					Czechia Verts/ALE Against (3) Marcel KOLAJA, Markéta GREGOROVÁ, Mikuláš PEKSA 3	Lithuania Verts/ALE For (1) Bronis ROPĖ Against (1) Stasys JAKELIŪNAS 2		Denmark Verts/ALE Against (2) Kira Marie PETER-HANSEN, Margrete AUKEN 2	Ireland Verts/ALE Against (1) Ciarán CUFFE 1		Belgium Verts/ALE Against (3) Philippe LAMBERTS, Sara MATTHIEU, Saskia BRICMONT 3		Italy Verts/ALE Against (3) Ignazio CORRAO, Piernicola PEDICINI, Rosa D'AMATO 3		Netherlands Verts/ALE Against (3) Bas EICKHOUT, Kim VAN SPARRENTAK, Tineke STRIK 3	Austria Verts/ALE Against (3) Monika VANA, Sarah WIENER, Thomas WAITZ 3	Portugal Verts/ALE Against (1) Francisco GUERREIRO 1	Spain Verts/ALE Against (4) Ana MIRANDA, Diana RIBA I GINER, Ernest URTASUN, Jordi SOLÉ 4	France Verts/ALE Against (12) Benoît BITEAU, Caroline ROOSE, Claude GRUFFAT, Damien CARÊME, David CORMAND, François ALFONSI, Gwendoline DELBOS-CORFIELD, Karima DELLI, Lydie MASSARD, Marie TOUSSAINT, Michèle RIVASI, Mounir SATOURI 12	Germany Verts/ALE Against (22) Alexandra GEESE, Anna CAVAZZINI, Anna DEPARNAY-GRUNENBERG, Damian BOESELAGER, Daniel FREUND, Erik MARQUARDT, Hannah NEUMANN, Henrike HAHN, Jutta PAULUS, Katrin LANGENSIEPEN, Malte GALLÉE, Manuela RIPA, Martin HÄUSLING, Michael BLOSS, Nico SEMSROTT, Niklas NIENASS, Patrick BREYER, Pierrette HERZBERGER-FOFANA, Rasmus ANDRESEN, Sergey LAGODINSKY, Ska KELLER, Terry REINTKE 22
S&D	109	Poland S&D For (3) Marek BELKA, Marek Paweł BALT, Robert BIEDROŃ Against (2) Bogusław LIBERADZKI, Leszek MILLER Abstain (1) Łukasz KOHUT 6	Hungary S&D For (4) Attila ARA-KOVÁCS, Csaba MOLNÁR, Klára DOBREV, Sándor RÓNAI Against (1) István UJHELYI 5	Latvia S&D Against (1) Nils UŠAKOVS 1	Estonia S&D For (1) Marina KALJURAND Abstain (1) Sven MIKSER 2		Finland S&D For (1) Miapetra KUMPULA-NATRI Against (1) Eero HEINÄLUOMA 2	Sweden S&D For (1) Carina OHLSSON Against (3) Evin INCIR, Heléne FRITZON, Ilan DE BASSO 4	Cyprus S&D Against (1) Demetris PAPADAKIS 1	Malta S&D Against (4) Alex AGIUS SALIBA, Alfred SANT, Cyrus ENGERER, Josianne CUTAJAR 4	Luxembourg S&D Against (1) Marc ANGEL 1	Croatia S&D For (1) Biljana BORZAN Against (3) Predrag Fred MATIĆ, Romana JERKOVIĆ, Tonino PICULA 4	Czechia S&D Against (1) Radka MAXOVÁ 1	Lithuania S&D Against (2) Juozas OLEKAS, Vilija BLINKEVIČIŪTĖ 2	Slovenia S&D Against (2) Matjaž NEMEC, Milan BRGLEZ 2	Denmark S&D Against (3) Christel SCHALDEMOSE, Marianne VIND, Niels FUGLSANG 3		Slovakia S&D Against (1) Robert HAJŠEL 1	Belgium S&D Against (2) Kathleen VAN BREMPT, Maria ARENA 2	Greece S&D Against (1) Nikos PAPANDREOU 1	Italy S&D For (3) Alessandra MORETTI, Irene TINAGLI, Patrizia TOIA Against (8) Achille VARIATI, Beatrice COVASSI, Daniela RONDINELLI, Elisabetta GUALMINI, Massimiliano SMERIGLIO, Mercedes BRESSO, Pietro BARTOLO, Pina PICIERNO 11	Romania S&D Against (4) Adrian-Dragoş BENEA, Maria GRAPINI, Mihai TUDOSE, Rovana PLUMB Abstain (2) Tudor CIUHODARU, Victor NEGRESCU 6	Netherlands S&D Against (3) Agnes JONGERIUS, Mohammed CHAHIM, Thijs REUTEN 3	Austria S&D Against (4) Andreas SCHIEDER, Evelyn REGNER, Günther SIDL, Hannes HEIDE Abstain (1) Theresa BIELOWSKI 5	Portugal S&D Against (8) Carlos ZORRINHO, Isabel CARVALHAIS, Isabel SANTOS, João ALBUQUERQUE, Margarida MARQUES, Maria-Manuel LEITÃO-MARQUES, Pedro SILVA PEREIRA, Sara CERDAS 8	Spain S&D Against (18) Alicia HOMS GINEL, Clara AGUILERA, Cristina MAESTRE MARTÍN DE ALMAGRO, César LUENA, Domènec RUIZ DEVESA, Eider GARDIAZABAL RUBIAL, Ibán GARCÍA DEL BLANCO, Inma RODRÍGUEZ-PIÑERO, Iratxe GARCÍA PÉREZ, Isabel GARCÍA MUÑOZ, Javi LÓPEZ, Javier MORENO SÁNCHEZ, Jonás FERNÁNDEZ, Laura BALLARÍN CEREZA, Marcos ROS SEMPERE, Mónica Silvana GONZÁLEZ, Nacho SÁNCHEZ AMOR, Nicolás GONZÁLEZ CASARES 18	France S&D For (1) Pascal DURAND Against (5) Aurore LALUCQ, Christophe CLERGEAU, Nora MEBAREK, Pierre LARROUTUROU, Sylvie GUILLAUME 6	Germany S&D Against (10) Bernd LANGE, Delara BURKHARDT, Jens GEIER, Karsten LUCKE, Matthias ECKE, Petra KAMMEREVERT, René REPASI, Thomas RUDNER, Tiemo WÖLKEN, Udo BULLMANN 10
Renew	87	Poland Renew Against (1) Róża THUN UND HOHENSTEIN 1	Hungary Renew Against (1) Katalin CSEH 1	Latvia Renew For (1) Ivars IJABS 1	Estonia Renew Against (3) Andrus ANSIP, Jana TOOM, Urmas PAET 3	Bulgaria Renew Against (3) Atidzhe ALIEVA-VELI, Ilhan KYUCHYUK, Iskra MIHAYLOVA 3	Finland Renew Against (2) Mauri PEKKARINEN, Nils TORVALDS 2	Sweden Renew For (1) Karin KARLSBRO Against (2) Abir AL-SAHLANI, Emma WIESNER 3			Luxembourg Renew Against (2) Charles GOERENS, Monica SEMEDO 2	Croatia Renew Against (1) Valter FLEGO 1	Czechia Renew Against (5) Dita CHARANZOVÁ, Martin HLAVÁČEK, Martina DLABAJOVÁ, Ondřej KNOTEK, Ondřej KOVAŘÍK 5	Lithuania Renew Abstain (1) Petras AUŠTREVIČIUS 1	Slovenia Renew Against (2) Irena JOVEVA, Klemen GROŠELJ 2	Denmark Renew For (1) Morten LØKKEGAARD Against (4) Asger CHRISTENSEN, Bergur Løkke RASMUSSEN, Karen MELCHIOR, Morten PETERSEN 5	Ireland Renew Against (2) Barry ANDREWS, Billy KELLEHER 2	Slovakia Renew Against (4) Jozef MIHÁL, Lucia ĎURIŠ NICHOLSONOVÁ, Martin HOJSÍK, Michal WIEZIK 4	Belgium Renew Against (4) Frédérique RIES, Guy VERHOFSTADT, Hilde VAUTMANS, Olivier CHASTEL 4	Greece Renew Against (1) Georgios KYRTSOS 1	Italy Renew Against (2) Giuseppe FERRANDINO, Marco ZULLO 2	Romania Renew For (1) Vlad GHEORGHE Against (3) Dragoş PÎSLARU, Dragoş TUDORACHE, Ramona STRUGARIU 4	Netherlands Renew Against (7) Bart GROOTHUIS, Caroline NAGTEGAAL, Catharina RINZEMA, Jan HUITEMA, Malik AZMANI, Samira RAFAELA, Sophia IN 'T VELD 7			Spain Renew For (1) Javier NART Against (8) Adrián VÁZQUEZ LÁZARA, Eva Maria POPTCHEVA, Izaskun BILBAO BARANDICA, Jordi CAÑAS, José Ramón BAUZÁ DÍAZ, Maite PAGAZAURTUNDÚA, María Soraya RODRÍGUEZ RAMOS, Susana SOLÍS PÉREZ 9	France Renew Against (18) Bernard GUETTA, Catherine AMALRIC, Christophe GRUDLER, Dominique RIQUET, Fabienne KELLER, Gilles BOYER, Ilana CICUREL, Irène TOLLERET, Jérémy DECERLE, Laurence FARRENG, Nathalie LOISEAU, Pascal CANFIN, Pierre KARLESKIND, Salima YENBOU, Sandro GOZI, Stéphane SÉJOURNÉ, Stéphanie YON-COURTIN, Valérie HAYER 18	Germany Renew Against (6) Andreas GLÜCK, Engin EROGLU, Jan-Christoph OETJEN, Moritz KÖRNER, Svenja HAHN, Ulrike MÜLLER 6
PPE	147	Poland PPE For (8) Adam JARUBAS, Andrzej HALICKI, Elżbieta Katarzyna ŁUKACIJEWSKA, Ewa KOPACZ, Jarosław KALINOWSKI, Magdalena ADAMOWICZ, Radosław SIKORSKI, Tomasz FRANKOWSKI Against (3) Danuta Maria HÜBNER, Janina OCHOJSKA, Jarosław DUDA Abstain (1) Jan OLBRYCHT 12		Latvia PPE For (1) Dace MELBĀRDE Against (2) Inese VAIDERE, Sandra KALNIETE 3	Estonia PPE Against (1) Riho TERRAS 1	Bulgaria PPE For (2) Andrey NOVAKOV, Radan KANEV Against (4) Alexander ALEXANDROV YORDANOV, Asim ADEMOV, Emil RADEV, Eva MAYDELL Abstain (1) Andrey KOVATCHEV 7	Finland PPE Against (1) Sirpa PIETIKÄINEN 1	Sweden PPE Abstain (3) Arba KOKALARI, Jörgen WARBORN, Tomas TOBÉ 3	Cyprus PPE Against (2) Eleni STAVROU, Loucas FOURLAS 2	Malta PPE Against (1) David CASA 1	Luxembourg PPE Against (2) Isabel WISELER-LIMA, Martine KEMP 2	Croatia PPE Against (3) Karlo RESSLER, Tomislav SOKOL, Željana ZOVKO 3	Czechia PPE For (2) Jiří POSPÍŠIL, Michaela ŠOJDROVÁ Against (1) Stanislav POLČÁK Abstain (2) Luděk NIEDERMAYER, Tomáš ZDECHOVSKÝ 5	Lithuania PPE Against (4) Andrius KUBILIUS, Aušra SEIBUTYTĖ, Liudas MAŽYLIS, Rasa JUKNEVIČIENĖ 4	Slovenia PPE Against (4) Franc BOGOVIČ, Ljudmila NOVAK, Milan ZVER, Romana TOMC 4	Denmark PPE Against (1) Pernille WEISS 1	Ireland PPE Against (5) Colm MARKEY, Deirdre CLUNE, Frances FITZGERALD, Maria WALSH, Seán KELLY 5	Slovakia PPE Against (3) Ivan ŠTEFANEC, Peter POLLÁK, Vladimír BILČÍK 3	Belgium PPE Against (4) Benoît LUTGEN, Cindy FRANSSEN, Pascal ARIMONT, Tom VANDENKENDELAERE 4	Greece PPE Against (6) Anna-Michelle ASIMAKOPOULOU, Manolis KEFALOGIANNIS, Maria SPYRAKI, Stelios KYMPOUROPOULOS, Theodoros ZAGORAKIS, Vangelis MEIMARAKIS 6	Italy PPE Against (9) Aldo PATRICIELLO, Francesca PEPPUCCI, Fulvio MARTUSCIELLO, Herbert DORFMANN, Isabella ADINOLFI, Lucia VUOLO, Massimiliano SALINI, Salvatore DE MEO, Stefania ZAMBELLI 9	Romania PPE For (1) Daniel BUDA Against (9) Cristian-Silviu BUŞOI, Eugen TOMAC, Gheorghe FALCĂ, Gheorghe-Vlad NISTOR, Iuliu WINKLER, Loránt VINCZE, Marian-Jean MARINESCU, Siegfried MUREŞAN, Traian BĂSESCU 10	Netherlands PPE For (1) Anja HAGA Against (4) Antonius MANDERS, Esther DE LANGE, Jeroen LENAERS, Tom BERENDSEN 5	Austria PPE Against (6) Alexander BERNHUBER, Angelika WINZIG, Christian SAGARTZ, Lukas MANDL, Othmar KARAS, Wolfram PIRCHNER 6	Portugal PPE Against (5) Carlos COELHO, Cláudia MONTEIRO DE AGUIAR, José Manuel FERNANDES, Lídia PEREIRA, Maria da Graça CARVALHO 5	Spain PPE Against (12) Ana COLLADO JIMÉNEZ, Antonio LÓPEZ-ISTÚRIZ WHITE, Dolors MONTSERRAT, Francisco José MILLÁN MON, Isabel BENJUMEA BENJUMEA, Javier ZARZALEJOS, José Manuel GARCÍA-MARGALLO Y MARFIL, Juan Ignacio ZOIDO ÁLVAREZ, Leopoldo LÓPEZ GIL, Pablo ARIAS ECHEVERRÍA, Pilar del CASTILLO VERA, Rosa ESTARÀS FERRAGUT 12	France PPE Against (6) Anne SANDER, Arnaud DANJEAN, Brice HORTEFEUX, François-Xavier BELLAMY, Laurence SAILLIET, Nathalie COLIN-OESTERLÉ 6	Germany PPE Against (27) Andreas SCHWAB, Angelika NIEBLER, Axel VOSS, Christian DOLESCHAL, Christian EHLER, Christine SCHNEIDER, Daniel CASPARY, David McALLISTER, Dennis RADTKE, Helmut GEUKING, Jens GIESEKE, Karolin BRAUNSBERGER-REINHOLD, Lena DÜPONT, Manfred WEBER, Markus FERBER, Markus PIEPER, Marlene MORTLER, Michael GAHLER, Monika HOHLMEIER, Niclas HERBST, Norbert LINS, Peter JAHR, Peter LIESE, Rainer WIELAND, Ralf SEEKATZ, Sabine VERHEYEN, Stefan BERGER 27