Events

Documents

• Text adopted by Parliament, single reading: T9-0172/2024
• Decision by Parliament: T9-0172/2024
• Debate in Parliament: Debate in Parliament
• Motion for a resolution: B9-0162/2024
• Motion for a resolution: B9-0162/2024
• Text adopted by Parliament, single reading: T9-0172/2024

Activities

• Clare DALY
  Plenary Speeches (1)

  • 2024/03/14 The time the European Commission takes to deal with requests for public access to documents (B9-0162/2024)

Votes

B9-0162/2024 – After § 2 – Am 14 #

		FR	CZ	PL	IT	HU	BE	NL	HR	SK	DK	EE	IE	LU	SE	FI	EL	BG	RO	LT	SI	MT	AT	LV	PT	ES	DE
	Total	68	20	44	51	12	18	27	12	10	11	7	13	4	13	10	4	11	17	8	7	3	12	5	17	46	71
Renew	79	France Renew For (20) Bernard GUETTA, Catherine AMALRIC, Catherine CHABAUD, Christophe GRUDLER, Dominique RIQUET, Fabienne KELLER, Gilles BOYER, Guy LAVOCAT, Ilana CICUREL, Irène TOLLERET, Jérémy DECERLE, Laurence FARRENG, Marie-Pierre VEDRENNE, Max ORVILLE, Nathalie LOISEAU, Pascal CANFIN, Salima YENBOU, Sandro GOZI, Stéphanie YON-COURTIN, Valérie HAYER 20	Czechia Renew For (4) Dita CHARANZOVÁ, Martin HLAVÁČEK, Ondřej KNOTEK, Ondřej KOVAŘÍK 4	Poland Renew For (1) Róża THUN UND HOHENSTEIN 1	Italy Renew For (3) Fabio Massimo CASTALDO, Giuseppe FERRANDINO, Nicola DANTI 3	Hungary Renew For (2) Anna Júlia DONÁTH, Katalin CSEH 2	Belgium Renew For (2) Hilde VAUTMANS, Olivier CHASTEL 2	Netherlands Renew For (6) Bart GROOTHUIS, Caroline NAGTEGAAL, Catharina RINZEMA, Jan HUITEMA, Malik AZMANI, Sophia IN 'T VELD 6	Croatia Renew For (1) Valter FLEGO 1	Slovakia Renew For (1) Michal WIEZIK 1	Denmark Renew For (4) Bergur Løkke RASMUSSEN, Erik POULSEN, Karen MELCHIOR, Morten LØKKEGAARD 4	Estonia Renew For (3) Andrus ANSIP, Jana TOOM, Urmas PAET 3	Ireland Renew For (2) Barry ANDREWS, Billy KELLEHER 2	Luxembourg Renew For (2) Charles GOERENS, Monica SEMEDO 2	Sweden Renew For (3) Abir AL-SAHLANI, Emma WIESNER, Karin KARLSBRO 3	Finland Renew For (2) Mauri PEKKARINEN, Nils TORVALDS 2	Greece Renew For (1) Georgios KYRTSOS 1	Bulgaria Renew For (3) Atidzhe ALIEVA-VELI, Ilhan KYUCHYUK, Iskra MIHAYLOVA 3	Romania Renew For (5) Alin MITUȚA, Dragoş PÎSLARU, Dragoş TUDORACHE, Vlad GHEORGHE, Vlad-Marius BOTOŞ 5	Lithuania Renew For (1) Petras AUŠTREVIČIUS 1	Slovenia Renew For (2) Irena JOVEVA, Klemen GROŠELJ 2					Spain Renew For (5) Javier NART, Jordi CAÑAS, José Ramón BAUZÁ DÍAZ, Maite PAGAZAURTUNDÚA, María Soraya RODRÍGUEZ RAMOS 5	Germany Renew For (6) Andreas GLÜCK, Engin EROGLU, Jan-Christoph OETJEN, Michael KAUCH, Moritz KÖRNER, Svenja HAHN 6
ECR	53	France ECR For (1) Nicolas BAY 1	Czechia ECR For (4) Alexandr VONDRA, Evžen TOŠENOVSKÝ, Jan ZAHRADIL, Veronika VRECIONOVÁ 4	Poland ECR For (25) Adam BIELAN, Andżelika Anna MOŻDŻANOWSKA, Anna FOTYGA, Anna ZALEWSKA, Beata KEMPA, Beata MAZUREK, Beata SZYDŁO, Bogdan RZOŃCA, Dominik TARCZYŃSKI, Elżbieta KRUK, Elżbieta RAFALSKA, Grzegorz TOBISZOWSKI, Izabela-Helena KLOC, Jacek SARYUSZ-WOLSKI, Jadwiga WIŚNIEWSKA, Joachim Stanisław BRUDZIŃSKI, Joanna KOPCIŃSKA, Kosma ZŁOTOWSKI, Krzysztof JURGIEL, Patryk JAKI, Rafał ROMANOWSKI, Ryszard CZARNECKI, Tomasz Piotr PORĘBA, Witold Jan WASZCZYKOWSKI, Zdzisław KRASNODĘBSKI 25	Italy ECR For (3) Denis NESCI, Elisabetta DE BLASIS, Sergio BERLATO 3		Belgium ECR For (3) Assita KANKO, Geert BOURGEOIS, Johan VAN OVERTVELDT 3	Netherlands ECR For (5) Bert-Jan RUISSEN, Dorien ROOKMAKER, Michiel HOOGEVEEN, Rob ROOKEN, Robert ROOS 5	Croatia ECR For (1) Ladislav ILČIĆ 1	Slovakia ECR For (1) Eugen JURZYCA 1					Sweden ECR For (1) Peter LUNDGREN Abstain (2) Charlie WEIMERS, Johan NISSINEN 3	Finland ECR For (1) Pirkko RUOHONEN-LERNER 1		Bulgaria ECR For (1) Andrey SLABAKOV 1	Romania ECR For (1) Cristian TERHEŞ 1							Spain ECR For (3) Hermann TERTSCH, Jorge BUXADÉ VILLALBA, Margarita DE LA PISA CARRIÓN 3	Germany ECR For (1) Lars Patrick BERG 1
ID	45	France ID For (16) André ROUGÉ, Annika BRUNA, Catherine GRISET, Dominique BILDE, Eric MINARDI, France JAMET, Gilles LEBRETON, Jean-Lin LACAPELLE, Jean-Paul GARRAUD, Jordan BARDELLA, Marie DAUCHY, Mathilde ANDROUËT, Patricia CHAGNON, Philippe OLIVIER, Thierry MARIANI, Virginie JORON 16	Czechia ID For (1) Ivan DAVID 1		Italy ID For (15) Alessandra BASSO, Alessandro PANZA, Anna BONFRISCO, Antonio Maria RINALDI, Elena LIZZI, Gianantonio DA RE, Gianna GANCIA, Marco CAMPOMENOSI, Marco ZANNI, Maria Veronica ROSSI, Matteo ADINOLFI, Paola GHIDONI, Rosanna CONTE, Silvia SARDONE, Susanna CECCARDI 15		Belgium ID For (3) Filip DE MAN, Gerolf ANNEMANS, Tom VANDENDRIESSCHE 3				Denmark ID For (1) Anders VISTISEN 1	Estonia ID For (1) Jaak MADISON 1											Austria ID For (3) Georg MAYER, Harald VILIMSKY, Roman HAIDER 3				Germany ID For (5) Bernhard ZIMNIOK, Guido REIL, Joachim KUHS, Markus BUCHHEIT, Sylvia LIMMER 5
NI	30	France NI For (1) Hervé JUVIN 1	Czechia NI For (1) Hynek BLAŠKO 1		Italy NI For (6) Dino GIARRUSSO, Laura FERRARA, Maria Angela DANZÌ, Mario FURORE, Sabrina PIGNEDOLI, Tiziana BEGHIN 6	Hungary NI For (7) Andor DELI, Andrea BOCSKOR, Edina TÓTH, Enikő GYŐRI, Ernő SCHALLER-BAROSS, Kinga GÁL, Márton GYÖNGYÖSI 7	Belgium NI Against (1) Marc TARABELLA 1	Netherlands NI Against (1) Marcel de GRAAFF 1	Croatia NI For (2) Ivan Vilibor SINČIĆ, Mislav KOLAKUŠIĆ 2	Slovakia NI For (2) Milan UHRÍK, Miroslav RADAČOVSKÝ Against (1) Katarína ROTH NEVEĎALOVÁ 3							Greece NI Against (1) Athanasios KONSTANTINOU Abstain (1) Eva KAILI 2		Romania NI For (1) Tudor CIUHODARU 1							Spain NI Abstain (3) Antoni COMÍN I OLIVERES, Carles PUIGDEMONT I CASAMAJÓ, Clara PONSATÍ OBIOLS 3	Germany NI For (1) Jörg MEUTHEN Against (1) Martin SONNEBORN 2
The Left	23	France The Left For (1) Anne-Sophie PELLETIER Against (5) Emmanuel MAUREL, Leila CHAIBI, Manon AUBRY, Marina MESURE, Younous OMARJEE 6	Czechia The Left For (1) Kateřina KONEČNÁ 1				Belgium The Left For (1) Marc BOTENGA 1	Netherlands The Left For (1) Anja HAZEKAMP 1			Denmark The Left For (1) Nikolaj VILLUMSEN 1		Ireland The Left For (4) Chris MACMANUS, Clare DALY, Luke Ming FLANAGAN, Mick WALLACE 4												Portugal The Left For (2) José GUSMÃO, Marisa MATIAS 2	Spain The Left For (3) Esther SANZ SELVA, Idoia VILLANUEVA RUIZ, Patricia CARO MAYA 3	Germany The Left For (2) Cornelia ERNST, Özlem DEMIREL Against (2) Helmut SCHOLZ, Martina MICHELS 4
Verts/ALE	59	France Verts/ALE Abstain (11) Benoît BITEAU, Caroline ROOSE, Claude GRUFFAT, Damien CARÊME, David CORMAND, François ALFONSI, François THIOLLET, Gwendoline DELBOS-CORFIELD, Lydie MASSARD, Marie TOUSSAINT, Mounir SATOURI 11	Czechia Verts/ALE For (3) Marcel KOLAJA, Markéta GREGOROVÁ, Mikuláš PEKSA 3	Poland Verts/ALE Abstain (1) Sylwia SPUREK 1	Italy Verts/ALE Abstain (3) Ignazio CORRAO, Piernicola PEDICINI, Rosa D'AMATO 3		Belgium Verts/ALE Abstain (3) Philippe LAMBERTS, Sara MATTHIEU, Saskia BRICMONT 3	Netherlands Verts/ALE Abstain (3) Bas EICKHOUT, Kim VAN SPARRENTAK, Tineke STRIK 3			Denmark Verts/ALE Abstain (1) Margrete AUKEN 1		Ireland Verts/ALE Abstain (2) Ciarán CUFFE, Grace O'SULLIVAN 2	Luxembourg Verts/ALE Abstain (1) Tilly METZ 1	Sweden Verts/ALE Abstain (2) Alice KUHNKE, Pär HOLMGREN 2	Finland Verts/ALE Abstain (3) Alviina ALAMETSÄ, Heidi HAUTALA, Ville NIINISTÖ 3				Lithuania Verts/ALE For (1) Stasys JAKELIŪNAS Abstain (1) Bronis ROPĖ 2			Austria Verts/ALE Abstain (2) Monika VANA, Thomas WAITZ 2		Portugal Verts/ALE Abstain (1) Francisco GUERREIRO 1	Spain Verts/ALE Against (2) Ana MIRANDA PAZ, Diana RIBA I GINER Abstain (1) Jordi SOLÉ 3	Germany Verts/ALE For (1) Patrick BREYER Abstain (17) Alexandra GEESE, Anna CAVAZZINI, Damian BOESELAGER, Daniel FREUND, Erik MARQUARDT, Hannah NEUMANN, Katrin LANGENSIEPEN, Manuela RIPA, Martin HÄUSLING, Michael BLOSS, Nico SEMSROTT, Rasmus ANDRESEN, Reinhard BÜTIKOFER, Sergey LAGODINSKY, Ska KELLER, Terry REINTKE, Viola VON CRAMON-TAUBADEL 18
S&D	106	France S&D For (1) Pierre LARROUTUROU Against (6) Aurore LALUCQ, Christophe CLERGEAU, Nora MEBAREK, Pascal DURAND, Raphaël GLUCKSMANN, Sylvie GUILLAUME 7	Czechia S&D Against (1) Radka MAXOVÁ 1	Poland S&D Against (5) Leszek MILLER, Marek Paweł BALT, Robert BIEDROŃ, Włodzimierz CIMOSZEWICZ, Łukasz KOHUT 5	Italy S&D Against (13) Achille VARIATI, Alessandra MORETTI, Beatrice COVASSI, Brando BENIFEI, Camilla LAURETI, Daniela RONDINELLI, Elisabetta GUALMINI, Franco ROBERTI, Massimiliano SMERIGLIO, Mercedes BRESSO, Paolo DE CASTRO, Patrizia TOIA, Pietro BARTOLO 13	Hungary S&D Against (3) Attila ARA-KOVÁCS, Klára DOBREV, Sándor RÓNAI 3	Belgium S&D Against (2) Kathleen VAN BREMPT, Maria ARENA 2	Netherlands S&D Against (6) Agnes JONGERIUS, Lara WOLTERS, Mohammed CHAHIM, Paul TANG, Thijs REUTEN, Vera TAX 6	Croatia S&D For (3) Biljana BORZAN, Predrag Fred MATIĆ, Tonino PICULA Against (1) Romana JERKOVIĆ 4	Slovakia S&D Against (1) Robert HAJŠEL 1	Denmark S&D Against (3) Christel SCHALDEMOSE, Marianne VIND, Niels FUGLSANG 3	Estonia S&D Against (2) Marina KALJURAND, Sven MIKSER 2				Finland S&D Against (1) Miapetra KUMPULA-NATRI 1	Greece S&D Against (1) Nikos PAPANDREOU 1	Bulgaria S&D Against (2) Elena YONCHEVA, Petar VITANOV 2	Romania S&D Against (3) Adrian-Dragoş BENEA, Maria GRAPINI, Rovana PLUMB 3	Lithuania S&D Against (2) Juozas OLEKAS, Vilija BLINKEVIČIŪTĖ 2	Slovenia S&D Against (2) Matjaž NEMEC, Milan BRGLEZ 2	Malta S&D Against (2) Alex AGIUS SALIBA, Alfred SANT 2	Austria S&D Against (5) Andreas SCHIEDER, Evelyn REGNER, Günther SIDL, Hannes HEIDE, Theresa BIELOWSKI 5	Latvia S&D Against (2) Andris AMERIKS, Nils UŠAKOVS 2	Portugal S&D Against (8) Carlos ZORRINHO, Isabel CARVALHAIS, Isabel SANTOS, Margarida MARQUES, Maria-Manuel LEITÃO-MARQUES, Pedro MARQUES, Pedro SILVA PEREIRA, Sara CERDAS 8	Spain S&D Against (18) Clara AGUILERA, Cristina MAESTRE, César LUENA, Domènec RUIZ DEVESA, Eider GARDIAZABAL RUBIAL, Ibán GARCÍA DEL BLANCO, Inma RODRÍGUEZ-PIÑERO, Iratxe GARCÍA PÉREZ, Isabel GARCÍA MUÑOZ, Javi LÓPEZ, Javier MORENO SÁNCHEZ, Juan Fernando LÓPEZ AGUILAR, Laura BALLARÍN CEREZA, Lina GÁLVEZ, Marcos ROS SEMPERE, Mónica Silvana GONZÁLEZ, Nacho SÁNCHEZ AMOR, Nicolás GONZÁLEZ CASARES 18	Germany S&D Against (12) Bernd LANGE, Birgit SIPPEL, Dietmar KÖSTER, Gabriele BISCHOFF, Jens GEIER, Joachim SCHUSTER, Maria NOICHL, Matthias ECKE, René REPASI, Thomas RUDNER, Tiemo WÖLKEN, Udo BULLMANN Abstain (1) Katarina BARLEY 13
PPE	126	France PPE For (6) Anne SANDER, Arnaud DANJEAN, Brice HORTEFEUX, Laurence SAILLIET, Nadine MORANO, Nathalie COLIN-OESTERLÉ 6	Czechia PPE For (2) Jiří POSPÍŠIL, Stanislav POLČÁK Against (3) Luděk NIEDERMAYER, Michaela ŠOJDROVÁ, Tomáš ZDECHOVSKÝ 5	Poland PPE Against (12) Adam JARUBAS, Danuta Maria HÜBNER, Elżbieta Katarzyna ŁUKACIJEWSKA, Ewa KOPACZ, Jan OLBRYCHT, Jarosław DUDA, Jarosław KALINOWSKI, Jerzy BUZEK, Magdalena ADAMOWICZ, Tomasz FRANKOWSKI, Witold PAHL, Włodzimierz KARPIŃSKI 12	Italy PPE Against (8) Caterina CHINNICI, Francesca PEPPUCCI, Herbert DORFMANN, Isabella ADINOLFI, Lucia VUOLO, Matteo GAZZINI, Salvatore DE MEO, Stefania ZAMBELLI 8		Belgium PPE For (1) Pascal ARIMONT Against (2) Cindy FRANSSEN, Tom VANDENKENDELAERE 3	Netherlands PPE For (1) Anja HAGA Against (4) Antonius MANDERS, Henk Jan ORMEL, Jeroen LENAERS, Tom BERENDSEN 5	Croatia PPE Against (4) Karlo RESSLER, Sunčana GLAVAK, Tomislav SOKOL, Željana ZOVKO 4	Slovakia PPE For (2) Miriam LEXMANN, Peter POLLÁK Against (2) Ivan ŠTEFANEC, Vladimír BILČÍK 4	Denmark PPE Against (1) Pernille WEISS 1	Estonia PPE Against (1) Riho TERRAS 1	Ireland PPE Against (5) Colm MARKEY, Deirdre CLUNE, Frances FITZGERALD, Maria WALSH, Seán KELLY 5	Luxembourg PPE Against (1) Martine KEMP 1	Sweden PPE Against (5) Arba KOKALARI, Jessica POLFJÄRD, Jörgen WARBORN, Sara SKYTTEDAL, Tomas TOBÉ 5	Finland PPE Against (3) Henna VIRKKUNEN, Petri SARVAMAA, Sirpa PIETIKÄINEN 3		Bulgaria PPE Against (5) Alexander ALEXANDROV YORDANOV, Andrey KOVATCHEV, Andrey NOVAKOV, Asim ADEMOV, Radan KANEV 5	Romania PPE Against (7) Eugen TOMAC, Iuliu WINKLER, Marian-Jean MARINESCU, Mircea-Gheorghe HAVA, Siegfried MUREŞAN, Traian BĂSESCU, Vasile BLAGA 7	Lithuania PPE Against (3) Andrius KUBILIUS, Aušra SEIBUTYTĖ, Liudas MAŽYLIS 3	Slovenia PPE Against (3) Franc BOGOVIČ, Ljudmila NOVAK, Romana TOMC 3	Malta PPE Against (1) David CASA 1	Austria PPE Against (2) Barbara THALER, Lukas MANDL 2	Latvia PPE Against (3) Dace MELBĀRDE, Inese VAIDERE, Sandra KALNIETE 3	Portugal PPE Against (6) Carlos COELHO, Cláudia MONTEIRO DE AGUIAR, José Manuel FERNANDES, Lídia PEREIRA, Maria da Graça CARVALHO, Nuno MELO 6	Spain PPE Against (11) Ana COLLADO JIMÉNEZ, Antonio LÓPEZ-ISTÚRIZ WHITE, Dolors MONTSERRAT, Francisco José MILLÁN MON, Gabriel MATO, Isabel BENJUMEA BENJUMEA, José Manuel GARCÍA-MARGALLO Y MARFIL, Juan Ignacio ZOIDO ÁLVAREZ, Leopoldo LÓPEZ GIL, Pablo ARIAS ECHEVERRÍA, Rosa ESTARÀS FERRAGUT 11	Germany PPE Against (22) Andreas SCHWAB, Angelika NIEBLER, Christian DOLESCHAL, Christine SCHNEIDER, Daniel CASPARY, David MCALLISTER, Karolin BRAUNSBERGER-REINHOLD, Manfred WEBER, Marion WALSMANN, Markus FERBER, Marlene MORTLER, Michael GAHLER, Monika HOHLMEIER, Niclas HERBST, Niels GEUKING, Norbert LINS, Peter JAHR, Peter LIESE, Rainer WIELAND, Ralf SEEKATZ, Sabine VERHEYEN, Sven SIMON 22

B9-0162/2024 – After § 4 – Am 5 #

		FR	CZ	PL	AT	HU	IT	BE	DK	EL	NL	SK	EE	IE	HR	SE	LU	FI	MT	RO	BG	SI	LT	LV	PT	DE	ES
	Total	68	19	46	12	12	51	17	11	4	27	10	7	13	12	14	5	9	3	18	10	7	9	6	18	74	49
Renew	80	France Renew For (20) Bernard GUETTA, Catherine AMALRIC, Catherine CHABAUD, Christophe GRUDLER, Dominique RIQUET, Fabienne KELLER, Gilles BOYER, Guy LAVOCAT, Ilana CICUREL, Irène TOLLERET, Jérémy DECERLE, Laurence FARRENG, Marie-Pierre VEDRENNE, Max ORVILLE, Nathalie LOISEAU, Pascal CANFIN, Salima YENBOU, Sandro GOZI, Stéphanie YON-COURTIN, Valérie HAYER 20	Czechia Renew For (4) Dita CHARANZOVÁ, Martin HLAVÁČEK, Ondřej KNOTEK, Ondřej KOVAŘÍK 4	Poland Renew For (1) Róża THUN UND HOHENSTEIN 1		Hungary Renew For (2) Anna Júlia DONÁTH, Katalin CSEH 2	Italy Renew For (3) Fabio Massimo CASTALDO, Giuseppe FERRANDINO, Nicola DANTI 3	Belgium Renew For (2) Hilde VAUTMANS, Olivier CHASTEL 2	Denmark Renew For (4) Bergur Løkke RASMUSSEN, Erik POULSEN, Karen MELCHIOR, Morten LØKKEGAARD 4	Greece Renew For (1) Georgios KYRTSOS 1	Netherlands Renew For (5) Bart GROOTHUIS, Caroline NAGTEGAAL, Jan HUITEMA, Malik AZMANI, Sophia IN 'T VELD Against (1) Catharina RINZEMA 6	Slovakia Renew For (1) Michal WIEZIK 1	Estonia Renew For (3) Andrus ANSIP, Jana TOOM, Urmas PAET 3	Ireland Renew For (2) Barry ANDREWS, Billy KELLEHER 2	Croatia Renew Against (1) Valter FLEGO 1	Sweden Renew For (3) Abir AL-SAHLANI, Emma WIESNER, Karin KARLSBRO 3	Luxembourg Renew For (2) Charles GOERENS, Monica SEMEDO 2	Finland Renew For (2) Mauri PEKKARINEN, Nils TORVALDS 2		Romania Renew For (6) Alin MITUȚA, Dacian CIOLOŞ, Dragoş PÎSLARU, Dragoş TUDORACHE, Vlad GHEORGHE, Vlad-Marius BOTOŞ 6	Bulgaria Renew For (2) Atidzhe ALIEVA-VELI, Iskra MIHAYLOVA 2	Slovenia Renew For (2) Irena JOVEVA, Klemen GROŠELJ 2	Lithuania Renew For (1) Petras AUŠTREVIČIUS 1	Latvia Renew For (1) Ivars IJABS 1		Germany Renew For (6) Andreas GLÜCK, Engin EROGLU, Jan-Christoph OETJEN, Michael KAUCH, Moritz KÖRNER, Svenja HAHN 6	Spain Renew For (5) Javier NART, Jordi CAÑAS, José Ramón BAUZÁ DÍAZ, Maite PAGAZAURTUNDÚA, María Soraya RODRÍGUEZ RAMOS 5
ECR	53	France ECR For (1) Nicolas BAY 1	Czechia ECR For (4) Alexandr VONDRA, Evžen TOŠENOVSKÝ, Jan ZAHRADIL, Veronika VRECIONOVÁ 4	Poland ECR For (25) Adam BIELAN, Andżelika Anna MOŻDŻANOWSKA, Anna FOTYGA, Anna ZALEWSKA, Beata KEMPA, Beata MAZUREK, Beata SZYDŁO, Bogdan RZOŃCA, Dominik TARCZYŃSKI, Elżbieta KRUK, Elżbieta RAFALSKA, Grzegorz TOBISZOWSKI, Izabela-Helena KLOC, Jacek SARYUSZ-WOLSKI, Jadwiga WIŚNIEWSKA, Joachim Stanisław BRUDZIŃSKI, Joanna KOPCIŃSKA, Kosma ZŁOTOWSKI, Krzysztof JURGIEL, Patryk JAKI, Rafał ROMANOWSKI, Ryszard CZARNECKI, Tomasz Piotr PORĘBA, Witold Jan WASZCZYKOWSKI, Zdzisław KRASNODĘBSKI 25			Italy ECR For (3) Denis NESCI, Elisabetta DE BLASIS, Sergio BERLATO 3	Belgium ECR Abstain (3) Assita KANKO, Geert BOURGEOIS, Johan VAN OVERTVELDT 3			Netherlands ECR For (5) Bert-Jan RUISSEN, Dorien ROOKMAKER, Michiel HOOGEVEEN, Rob ROOKEN, Robert ROOS 5	Slovakia ECR For (1) Eugen JURZYCA 1			Croatia ECR For (1) Ladislav ILČIĆ 1	Sweden ECR For (3) Charlie WEIMERS, Johan NISSINEN, Peter LUNDGREN 3		Finland ECR For (1) Pirkko RUOHONEN-LERNER 1		Romania ECR For (1) Cristian TERHEŞ 1	Bulgaria ECR For (1) Andrey SLABAKOV 1					Germany ECR For (1) Lars Patrick BERG 1	Spain ECR For (3) Hermann TERTSCH, Jorge BUXADÉ VILLALBA, Margarita DE LA PISA CARRIÓN 3
ID	48	France ID For (16) André ROUGÉ, Annika BRUNA, Aurélia BEIGNEUX, Catherine GRISET, Dominique BILDE, Eric MINARDI, France JAMET, Gilles LEBRETON, Jean-Paul GARRAUD, Jordan BARDELLA, Marie DAUCHY, Mathilde ANDROUËT, Patricia CHAGNON, Philippe OLIVIER, Thierry MARIANI, Virginie JORON 16	Czechia ID For (1) Ivan DAVID 1		Austria ID For (3) Georg MAYER, Harald VILIMSKY, Roman HAIDER 3		Italy ID For (15) Alessandra BASSO, Alessandro PANZA, Anna BONFRISCO, Antonio Maria RINALDI, Elena LIZZI, Gianantonio DA RE, Gianna GANCIA, Marco CAMPOMENOSI, Marco ZANNI, Maria Veronica ROSSI, Matteo ADINOLFI, Paola GHIDONI, Rosanna CONTE, Silvia SARDONE, Susanna CECCARDI 15	Belgium ID For (3) Filip DE MAN, Gerolf ANNEMANS, Tom VANDENDRIESSCHE 3	Denmark ID For (1) Anders VISTISEN 1				Estonia ID For (1) Jaak MADISON 1													Germany ID For (8) Bernhard ZIMNIOK, Christine ANDERSON, Guido REIL, Gunnar BECK, Joachim KUHS, Markus BUCHHEIT, Nicolaus FEST, Sylvia LIMMER 8
NI	30	France NI For (1) Hervé JUVIN 1	Czechia NI For (1) Hynek BLAŠKO 1			Hungary NI For (7) Andor DELI, Andrea BOCSKOR, Edina TÓTH, Enikő GYŐRI, Ernő SCHALLER-BAROSS, Kinga GÁL, Márton GYÖNGYÖSI 7	Italy NI For (5) Laura FERRARA, Maria Angela DANZÌ, Mario FURORE, Sabrina PIGNEDOLI, Tiziana BEGHIN Against (1) Dino GIARRUSSO 6	Belgium NI Against (1) Marc TARABELLA 1		Greece NI For (2) Athanasios KONSTANTINOU, Eva KAILI 2	Netherlands NI For (1) Marcel de GRAAFF 1	Slovakia NI For (2) Milan UHRÍK, Miroslav RADAČOVSKÝ Against (1) Katarína ROTH NEVEĎALOVÁ 3			Croatia NI For (2) Ivan Vilibor SINČIĆ, Mislav KOLAKUŠIĆ 2					Romania NI For (1) Tudor CIUHODARU 1						Germany NI For (1) Jörg MEUTHEN Against (1) Martin SONNEBORN 2	Spain NI Abstain (3) Antoni COMÍN I OLIVERES, Carles PUIGDEMONT I CASAMAJÓ, Clara PONSATÍ OBIOLS 3
The Left	24	France The Left For (2) Anne-Sophie PELLETIER, Emmanuel MAUREL Against (3) Leila CHAIBI, Manon AUBRY, Marina MESURE 5	Czechia The Left For (1) Kateřina KONEČNÁ 1					Belgium The Left For (1) Marc BOTENGA 1	Denmark The Left For (1) Nikolaj VILLUMSEN 1		Netherlands The Left For (1) Anja HAZEKAMP 1			Ireland The Left For (4) Chris MACMANUS, Clare DALY, Luke Ming FLANAGAN, Mick WALLACE 4		Sweden The Left Against (1) Malin BJÖRK 1									Portugal The Left For (3) José GUSMÃO, Marisa MATIAS, Sandra PEREIRA 3	Germany The Left For (2) Cornelia ERNST, Özlem DEMIREL Against (1) Martina MICHELS 3	Spain The Left For (4) Esther SANZ SELVA, Eugenia RODRÍGUEZ PALOP, Idoia VILLANUEVA RUIZ, Patricia CARO MAYA 4
Verts/ALE	59	France Verts/ALE Abstain (11) Caroline ROOSE, Claude GRUFFAT, Damien CARÊME, David CORMAND, François ALFONSI, François THIOLLET, Gwendoline DELBOS-CORFIELD, Karima DELLI, Lydie MASSARD, Marie TOUSSAINT, Mounir SATOURI 11	Czechia Verts/ALE For (3) Marcel KOLAJA, Markéta GREGOROVÁ, Mikuláš PEKSA 3	Poland Verts/ALE Abstain (1) Sylwia SPUREK 1	Austria Verts/ALE Abstain (2) Monika VANA, Thomas WAITZ 2		Italy Verts/ALE Abstain (3) Ignazio CORRAO, Piernicola PEDICINI, Rosa D'AMATO 3	Belgium Verts/ALE Abstain (3) Philippe LAMBERTS, Sara MATTHIEU, Saskia BRICMONT 3	Denmark Verts/ALE Abstain (1) Margrete AUKEN 1		Netherlands Verts/ALE Abstain (3) Bas EICKHOUT, Kim VAN SPARRENTAK, Tineke STRIK 3			Ireland Verts/ALE Abstain (2) Ciarán CUFFE, Grace O'SULLIVAN 2		Sweden Verts/ALE Abstain (2) Alice KUHNKE, Pär HOLMGREN 2	Luxembourg Verts/ALE Abstain (1) Tilly METZ 1	Finland Verts/ALE Abstain (2) Alviina ALAMETSÄ, Ville NIINISTÖ 2					Lithuania Verts/ALE For (1) Stasys JAKELIŪNAS Abstain (1) Bronis ROPĖ 2		Portugal Verts/ALE Abstain (1) Francisco GUERREIRO 1	Germany Verts/ALE For (1) Patrick BREYER Abstain (18) Alexandra GEESE, Anna CAVAZZINI, Anna DEPARNAY-GRUNENBERG, Damian BOESELAGER, Daniel FREUND, Erik MARQUARDT, Hannah NEUMANN, Katrin LANGENSIEPEN, Manuela RIPA, Martin HÄUSLING, Michael BLOSS, Nico SEMSROTT, Pierrette HERZBERGER-FOFANA, Reinhard BÜTIKOFER, Sergey LAGODINSKY, Ska KELLER, Terry REINTKE, Viola VON CRAMON-TAUBADEL 19	Spain Verts/ALE Against (2) Ana MIRANDA PAZ, Diana RIBA I GINER Abstain (1) Jordi SOLÉ 3
S&D	109	France S&D Against (6) Aurore LALUCQ, Christophe CLERGEAU, Nora MEBAREK, Pascal DURAND, Raphaël GLUCKSMANN, Sylvie GUILLAUME Abstain (1) Pierre LARROUTUROU 7	Czechia S&D Against (1) Radka MAXOVÁ 1	Poland S&D Against (6) Bogusław LIBERADZKI, Leszek MILLER, Marek Paweł BALT, Robert BIEDROŃ, Włodzimierz CIMOSZEWICZ, Łukasz KOHUT 6	Austria S&D For (5) Andreas SCHIEDER, Evelyn REGNER, Günther SIDL, Hannes HEIDE, Theresa BIELOWSKI 5	Hungary S&D Against (3) Attila ARA-KOVÁCS, Klára DOBREV, Sándor RÓNAI 3	Italy S&D Against (13) Achille VARIATI, Alessandra MORETTI, Beatrice COVASSI, Brando BENIFEI, Camilla LAURETI, Daniela RONDINELLI, Elisabetta GUALMINI, Franco ROBERTI, Massimiliano SMERIGLIO, Mercedes BRESSO, Paolo DE CASTRO, Patrizia TOIA, Pietro BARTOLO 13	Belgium S&D Against (1) Maria ARENA Abstain (1) Kathleen VAN BREMPT 2	Denmark S&D Against (3) Christel SCHALDEMOSE, Marianne VIND, Niels FUGLSANG 3	Greece S&D Against (1) Nikos PAPANDREOU 1	Netherlands S&D Against (6) Agnes JONGERIUS, Lara WOLTERS, Mohammed CHAHIM, Paul TANG, Thijs REUTEN, Vera TAX 6	Slovakia S&D Against (1) Robert HAJŠEL 1	Estonia S&D Against (2) Marina KALJURAND, Sven MIKSER 2		Croatia S&D For (3) Biljana BORZAN, Predrag Fred MATIĆ, Tonino PICULA Against (1) Romana JERKOVIĆ 4		Luxembourg S&D Against (1) Marc ANGEL 1	Finland S&D Against (1) Miapetra KUMPULA-NATRI 1	Malta S&D For (1) Alex AGIUS SALIBA Against (1) Alfred SANT 2	Romania S&D Against (3) Adrian-Dragoş BENEA, Maria GRAPINI, Rovana PLUMB 3	Bulgaria S&D Against (2) Elena YONCHEVA, Petar VITANOV 2	Slovenia S&D Against (2) Matjaž NEMEC, Milan BRGLEZ 2	Lithuania S&D Against (2) Juozas OLEKAS, Vilija BLINKEVIČIŪTĖ 2	Latvia S&D Against (2) Andris AMERIKS, Nils UŠAKOVS 2	Portugal S&D Against (8) Carlos ZORRINHO, Isabel CARVALHAIS, Isabel SANTOS, Margarida MARQUES, Maria-Manuel LEITÃO-MARQUES, Pedro MARQUES, Pedro SILVA PEREIRA, Sara CERDAS 8	Germany S&D Against (13) Bernd LANGE, Birgit SIPPEL, Dietmar KÖSTER, Gabriele BISCHOFF, Jens GEIER, Joachim SCHUSTER, Katarina BARLEY, Maria NOICHL, Matthias ECKE, René REPASI, Thomas RUDNER, Tiemo WÖLKEN, Udo BULLMANN 13	Spain S&D Against (19) Alicia HOMS GINEL, Clara AGUILERA, Cristina MAESTRE, César LUENA, Domènec RUIZ DEVESA, Eider GARDIAZABAL RUBIAL, Ibán GARCÍA DEL BLANCO, Inma RODRÍGUEZ-PIÑERO, Iratxe GARCÍA PÉREZ, Isabel GARCÍA MUÑOZ, Javi LÓPEZ, Javier MORENO SÁNCHEZ, Juan Fernando LÓPEZ AGUILAR, Laura BALLARÍN CEREZA, Lina GÁLVEZ, Marcos ROS SEMPERE, Mónica Silvana GONZÁLEZ, Nacho SÁNCHEZ AMOR, Nicolás GONZÁLEZ CASARES 19
PPE	128	France PPE For (7) Anne SANDER, Arnaud DANJEAN, Brice HORTEFEUX, François-Xavier BELLAMY, Laurence SAILLIET, Nadine MORANO, Nathalie COLIN-OESTERLÉ 7	Czechia PPE For (1) Jiří POSPÍŠIL Against (3) Luděk NIEDERMAYER, Michaela ŠOJDROVÁ, Stanislav POLČÁK 4	Poland PPE Against (13) Adam JARUBAS, Andrzej HALICKI, Danuta Maria HÜBNER, Elżbieta Katarzyna ŁUKACIJEWSKA, Ewa KOPACZ, Jan OLBRYCHT, Jarosław DUDA, Jarosław KALINOWSKI, Jerzy BUZEK, Magdalena ADAMOWICZ, Tomasz FRANKOWSKI, Witold PAHL, Włodzimierz KARPIŃSKI 13	Austria PPE Against (2) Barbara THALER, Lukas MANDL 2		Italy PPE Against (8) Caterina CHINNICI, Francesca PEPPUCCI, Herbert DORFMANN, Isabella ADINOLFI, Lucia VUOLO, Matteo GAZZINI, Salvatore DE MEO, Stefania ZAMBELLI 8	Belgium PPE For (1) Pascal ARIMONT Against (1) Cindy FRANSSEN 2	Denmark PPE Against (1) Pernille WEISS 1		Netherlands PPE Against (4) Antonius MANDERS, Henk Jan ORMEL, Jeroen LENAERS, Tom BERENDSEN Abstain (1) Anja HAGA 5	Slovakia PPE For (1) Miriam LEXMANN Against (2) Ivan ŠTEFANEC, Vladimír BILČÍK Abstain (1) Peter POLLÁK 4	Estonia PPE Against (1) Riho TERRAS 1	Ireland PPE Against (5) Colm MARKEY, Deirdre CLUNE, Frances FITZGERALD, Maria WALSH, Seán KELLY 5	Croatia PPE Against (4) Karlo RESSLER, Sunčana GLAVAK, Tomislav SOKOL, Željana ZOVKO 4	Sweden PPE Against (5) Arba KOKALARI, Jessica POLFJÄRD, Jörgen WARBORN, Sara SKYTTEDAL, Tomas TOBÉ 5	Luxembourg PPE Against (1) Martine KEMP 1	Finland PPE Against (3) Henna VIRKKUNEN, Petri SARVAMAA, Sirpa PIETIKÄINEN 3	Malta PPE Against (1) David CASA 1	Romania PPE Against (7) Daniel BUDA, Iuliu WINKLER, Marian-Jean MARINESCU, Mircea-Gheorghe HAVA, Siegfried MUREŞAN, Traian BĂSESCU, Vasile BLAGA 7	Bulgaria PPE Against (4) Alexander ALEXANDROV YORDANOV, Andrey KOVATCHEV, Andrey NOVAKOV, Asim ADEMOV Abstain (1) Radan KANEV 5	Slovenia PPE Against (3) Franc BOGOVIČ, Ljudmila NOVAK, Romana TOMC 3	Lithuania PPE Against (4) Andrius KUBILIUS, Aušra SEIBUTYTĖ, Liudas MAŽYLIS, Rasa JUKNEVIČIENĖ 4	Latvia PPE Against (3) Dace MELBĀRDE, Inese VAIDERE, Sandra KALNIETE 3	Portugal PPE Against (6) Carlos COELHO, Cláudia MONTEIRO DE AGUIAR, José Manuel FERNANDES, Lídia PEREIRA, Maria da Graça CARVALHO, Nuno MELO 6	Germany PPE Against (22) Andreas SCHWAB, Angelika NIEBLER, Christian DOLESCHAL, Christine SCHNEIDER, Daniel CASPARY, David MCALLISTER, Karolin BRAUNSBERGER-REINHOLD, Manfred WEBER, Marion WALSMANN, Markus FERBER, Marlene MORTLER, Michael GAHLER, Monika HOHLMEIER, Niclas HERBST, Niels GEUKING, Norbert LINS, Peter JAHR, Peter LIESE, Rainer WIELAND, Ralf SEEKATZ, Sabine VERHEYEN, Sven SIMON 22	Spain PPE Against (12) Ana COLLADO JIMÉNEZ, Antonio LÓPEZ-ISTÚRIZ WHITE, Dolors MONTSERRAT, Francisco José MILLÁN MON, Gabriel MATO, Isabel BENJUMEA BENJUMEA, Javier ZARZALEJOS, José Manuel GARCÍA-MARGALLO Y MARFIL, Juan Ignacio ZOIDO ÁLVAREZ, Leopoldo LÓPEZ GIL, Pablo ARIAS ECHEVERRÍA, Rosa ESTARÀS FERRAGUT 12

B9-0162/2024 – After § 4 – Am 6 #

		PL	FR	IT	RO	CZ	HR	IE	SK	SE	NL	BG	DE	BE	HU	FI	EE	DK	SI	LT	EL	LV	LU	PT	MT	ES	AT
	Total	46	70	49	18	20	12	13	10	14	27	11	72	18	12	9	7	11	7	9	4	6	5	17	3	48	12
PPE	130	Poland PPE For (12) Adam JARUBAS, Andrzej HALICKI, Danuta Maria HÜBNER, Elżbieta Katarzyna ŁUKACIJEWSKA, Ewa KOPACZ, Jan OLBRYCHT, Jarosław DUDA, Jarosław KALINOWSKI, Jerzy BUZEK, Magdalena ADAMOWICZ, Tomasz FRANKOWSKI, Włodzimierz KARPIŃSKI Abstain (1) Witold PAHL 13	France PPE For (7) Anne SANDER, Arnaud DANJEAN, Brice HORTEFEUX, François-Xavier BELLAMY, Laurence SAILLIET, Nadine MORANO, Nathalie COLIN-OESTERLÉ 7	Italy PPE For (7) Caterina CHINNICI, Francesca PEPPUCCI, Herbert DORFMANN, Isabella ADINOLFI, Lucia VUOLO, Matteo GAZZINI, Salvatore DE MEO Against (1) Stefania ZAMBELLI 8	Romania PPE For (8) Daniel BUDA, Eugen TOMAC, Iuliu WINKLER, Marian-Jean MARINESCU, Mircea-Gheorghe HAVA, Siegfried MUREŞAN, Traian BĂSESCU, Vasile BLAGA 8	Czechia PPE For (5) Jiří POSPÍŠIL, Luděk NIEDERMAYER, Michaela ŠOJDROVÁ, Stanislav POLČÁK, Tomáš ZDECHOVSKÝ 5	Croatia PPE For (4) Karlo RESSLER, Sunčana GLAVAK, Tomislav SOKOL, Željana ZOVKO 4	Ireland PPE For (5) Colm MARKEY, Deirdre CLUNE, Frances FITZGERALD, Maria WALSH, Seán KELLY 5	Slovakia PPE For (4) Ivan ŠTEFANEC, Miriam LEXMANN, Peter POLLÁK, Vladimír BILČÍK 4	Sweden PPE For (5) Arba KOKALARI, Jessica POLFJÄRD, Jörgen WARBORN, Sara SKYTTEDAL, Tomas TOBÉ 5	Netherlands PPE For (5) Anja HAGA, Antonius MANDERS, Henk Jan ORMEL, Jeroen LENAERS, Tom BERENDSEN 5	Bulgaria PPE For (5) Alexander ALEXANDROV YORDANOV, Andrey KOVATCHEV, Andrey NOVAKOV, Asim ADEMOV, Radan KANEV 5	Germany PPE For (21) Andreas SCHWAB, Angelika NIEBLER, Christian DOLESCHAL, Christine SCHNEIDER, Daniel CASPARY, David MCALLISTER, Karolin BRAUNSBERGER-REINHOLD, Manfred WEBER, Marion WALSMANN, Markus FERBER, Marlene MORTLER, Michael GAHLER, Monika HOHLMEIER, Niels GEUKING, Norbert LINS, Peter JAHR, Peter LIESE, Rainer WIELAND, Ralf SEEKATZ, Sabine VERHEYEN, Sven SIMON Against (1) Niclas HERBST 22	Belgium PPE For (3) Cindy FRANSSEN, Pascal ARIMONT, Tom VANDENKENDELAERE 3		Finland PPE For (3) Henna VIRKKUNEN, Petri SARVAMAA, Sirpa PIETIKÄINEN 3	Estonia PPE For (1) Riho TERRAS 1	Denmark PPE For (1) Pernille WEISS 1	Slovenia PPE For (3) Franc BOGOVIČ, Ljudmila NOVAK, Romana TOMC 3	Lithuania PPE For (4) Andrius KUBILIUS, Aušra SEIBUTYTĖ, Liudas MAŽYLIS, Rasa JUKNEVIČIENĖ 4		Latvia PPE For (3) Dace MELBĀRDE, Inese VAIDERE, Sandra KALNIETE 3	Luxembourg PPE For (1) Martine KEMP 1	Portugal PPE For (6) Carlos COELHO, Cláudia MONTEIRO DE AGUIAR, José Manuel FERNANDES, Lídia PEREIRA, Maria da Graça CARVALHO, Nuno MELO 6	Malta PPE For (1) David CASA 1	Spain PPE For (11) Ana COLLADO JIMÉNEZ, Antonio LÓPEZ-ISTÚRIZ WHITE, Dolors MONTSERRAT, Francisco José MILLÁN MON, Gabriel MATO, Isabel BENJUMEA BENJUMEA, Javier ZARZALEJOS, José Manuel GARCÍA-MARGALLO Y MARFIL, Leopoldo LÓPEZ GIL, Pablo ARIAS ECHEVERRÍA, Rosa ESTARÀS FERRAGUT 11	Austria PPE For (2) Barbara THALER, Lukas MANDL 2
Renew	80	Poland Renew For (1) Róża THUN UND HOHENSTEIN 1	France Renew For (20) Bernard GUETTA, Catherine AMALRIC, Catherine CHABAUD, Christophe GRUDLER, Dominique RIQUET, Fabienne KELLER, Gilles BOYER, Guy LAVOCAT, Ilana CICUREL, Irène TOLLERET, Jérémy DECERLE, Laurence FARRENG, Marie-Pierre VEDRENNE, Max ORVILLE, Nathalie LOISEAU, Pascal CANFIN, Salima YENBOU, Sandro GOZI, Stéphanie YON-COURTIN, Valérie HAYER 20	Italy Renew For (3) Fabio Massimo CASTALDO, Giuseppe FERRANDINO, Nicola DANTI 3	Romania Renew For (5) Alin MITUȚA, Dragoş PÎSLARU, Dragoş TUDORACHE, Vlad GHEORGHE, Vlad-Marius BOTOŞ 5	Czechia Renew For (4) Dita CHARANZOVÁ, Martin HLAVÁČEK, Ondřej KNOTEK, Ondřej KOVAŘÍK 4	Croatia Renew Against (1) Valter FLEGO 1	Ireland Renew For (2) Barry ANDREWS, Billy KELLEHER 2	Slovakia Renew For (1) Michal WIEZIK 1	Sweden Renew For (3) Abir AL-SAHLANI, Emma WIESNER, Karin KARLSBRO 3	Netherlands Renew For (5) Bart GROOTHUIS, Caroline NAGTEGAAL, Jan HUITEMA, Malik AZMANI, Sophia IN 'T VELD Against (1) Catharina RINZEMA 6	Bulgaria Renew For (3) Atidzhe ALIEVA-VELI, Ilhan KYUCHYUK, Iskra MIHAYLOVA 3	Germany Renew For (6) Andreas GLÜCK, Engin EROGLU, Jan-Christoph OETJEN, Michael KAUCH, Moritz KÖRNER, Svenja HAHN 6	Belgium Renew For (2) Hilde VAUTMANS, Olivier CHASTEL 2	Hungary Renew For (2) Anna Júlia DONÁTH, Katalin CSEH 2	Finland Renew For (2) Mauri PEKKARINEN, Nils TORVALDS 2	Estonia Renew For (3) Andrus ANSIP, Jana TOOM, Urmas PAET 3	Denmark Renew For (4) Bergur Løkke RASMUSSEN, Erik POULSEN, Karen MELCHIOR, Morten LØKKEGAARD 4	Slovenia Renew For (2) Irena JOVEVA, Klemen GROŠELJ 2	Lithuania Renew For (1) Petras AUŠTREVIČIUS 1	Greece Renew For (1) Georgios KYRTSOS 1	Latvia Renew For (1) Ivars IJABS 1	Luxembourg Renew For (2) Charles GOERENS, Monica SEMEDO 2			Spain Renew For (5) Javier NART, Jordi CAÑAS, José Ramón BAUZÁ DÍAZ, Maite PAGAZAURTUNDÚA, María Soraya RODRÍGUEZ RAMOS 5
ECR	53	Poland ECR For (25) Adam BIELAN, Andżelika Anna MOŻDŻANOWSKA, Anna FOTYGA, Anna ZALEWSKA, Beata KEMPA, Beata MAZUREK, Beata SZYDŁO, Bogdan RZOŃCA, Dominik TARCZYŃSKI, Elżbieta KRUK, Elżbieta RAFALSKA, Grzegorz TOBISZOWSKI, Izabela-Helena KLOC, Jacek SARYUSZ-WOLSKI, Jadwiga WIŚNIEWSKA, Joachim Stanisław BRUDZIŃSKI, Joanna KOPCIŃSKA, Kosma ZŁOTOWSKI, Krzysztof JURGIEL, Patryk JAKI, Rafał ROMANOWSKI, Ryszard CZARNECKI, Tomasz Piotr PORĘBA, Witold Jan WASZCZYKOWSKI, Zdzisław KRASNODĘBSKI 25	France ECR For (1) Nicolas BAY 1	Italy ECR For (3) Denis NESCI, Elisabetta DE BLASIS, Sergio BERLATO 3	Romania ECR For (1) Cristian TERHEŞ 1	Czechia ECR For (4) Alexandr VONDRA, Evžen TOŠENOVSKÝ, Jan ZAHRADIL, Veronika VRECIONOVÁ 4	Croatia ECR For (1) Ladislav ILČIĆ 1		Slovakia ECR For (1) Eugen JURZYCA 1	Sweden ECR For (3) Charlie WEIMERS, Johan NISSINEN, Peter LUNDGREN 3	Netherlands ECR For (5) Bert-Jan RUISSEN, Dorien ROOKMAKER, Michiel HOOGEVEEN, Rob ROOKEN, Robert ROOS 5	Bulgaria ECR For (1) Andrey SLABAKOV 1	Germany ECR For (1) Lars Patrick BERG 1	Belgium ECR For (3) Assita KANKO, Geert BOURGEOIS, Johan VAN OVERTVELDT 3		Finland ECR For (1) Pirkko RUOHONEN-LERNER 1										Spain ECR For (3) Hermann TERTSCH, Jorge BUXADÉ VILLALBA, Margarita DE LA PISA CARRIÓN 3
ID	48		France ID For (17) André ROUGÉ, Annika BRUNA, Aurélia BEIGNEUX, Catherine GRISET, Dominique BILDE, Eric MINARDI, France JAMET, Gilles LEBRETON, Jean-Lin LACAPELLE, Jean-Paul GARRAUD, Jordan BARDELLA, Marie DAUCHY, Mathilde ANDROUËT, Patricia CHAGNON, Philippe OLIVIER, Thierry MARIANI, Virginie JORON 17	Italy ID For (14) Alessandra BASSO, Alessandro PANZA, Anna BONFRISCO, Antonio Maria RINALDI, Elena LIZZI, Gianantonio DA RE, Gianna GANCIA, Marco ZANNI, Maria Veronica ROSSI, Matteo ADINOLFI, Paola GHIDONI, Rosanna CONTE, Silvia SARDONE, Susanna CECCARDI 14		Czechia ID For (1) Ivan DAVID 1							Germany ID For (8) Bernhard ZIMNIOK, Christine ANDERSON, Guido REIL, Gunnar BECK, Joachim KUHS, Markus BUCHHEIT, Nicolaus FEST, Sylvia LIMMER 8	Belgium ID For (3) Filip DE MAN, Gerolf ANNEMANS, Tom VANDENDRIESSCHE 3			Estonia ID For (1) Jaak MADISON 1	Denmark ID For (1) Anders VISTISEN 1									Austria ID For (3) Georg MAYER, Harald VILIMSKY, Roman HAIDER 3
NI	29		France NI For (1) Hervé JUVIN 1	Italy NI For (4) Laura FERRARA, Maria Angela DANZÌ, Sabrina PIGNEDOLI, Tiziana BEGHIN Against (1) Dino GIARRUSSO 5	Romania NI For (1) Tudor CIUHODARU 1	Czechia NI For (1) Hynek BLAŠKO 1	Croatia NI For (2) Ivan Vilibor SINČIĆ, Mislav KOLAKUŠIĆ 2		Slovakia NI For (3) Katarína ROTH NEVEĎALOVÁ, Milan UHRÍK, Miroslav RADAČOVSKÝ 3		Netherlands NI For (1) Marcel de GRAAFF 1		Germany NI For (1) Jörg MEUTHEN Against (1) Martin SONNEBORN 2	Belgium NI Against (1) Marc TARABELLA 1	Hungary NI For (7) Andor DELI, Andrea BOCSKOR, Edina TÓTH, Enikő GYŐRI, Ernő SCHALLER-BAROSS, Kinga GÁL, Márton GYÖNGYÖSI 7						Greece NI For (2) Athanasios KONSTANTINOU, Eva KAILI 2					Spain NI Against (3) Antoni COMÍN I OLIVERES, Carles PUIGDEMONT I CASAMAJÓ, Clara PONSATÍ OBIOLS 3
The Left	22		France The Left For (2) Anne-Sophie PELLETIER, Emmanuel MAUREL Against (3) Leila CHAIBI, Manon AUBRY, Marina MESURE 5			Czechia The Left For (1) Kateřina KONEČNÁ 1		Ireland The Left For (4) Chris MACMANUS, Clare DALY, Luke Ming FLANAGAN, Mick WALLACE 4		Sweden The Left Against (1) Malin BJÖRK 1	Netherlands The Left For (1) Anja HAZEKAMP 1		Germany The Left For (2) Cornelia ERNST, Özlem DEMIREL 2	Belgium The Left For (1) Marc BOTENGA 1				Denmark The Left For (1) Nikolaj VILLUMSEN 1						Portugal The Left For (2) José GUSMÃO, Marisa MATIAS 2		Spain The Left For (4) Esther SANZ SELVA, Eugenia RODRÍGUEZ PALOP, Idoia VILLANUEVA RUIZ, Patricia CARO MAYA 4
Verts/ALE	61	Poland Verts/ALE Against (1) Sylwia SPUREK 1	France Verts/ALE Against (11) Caroline ROOSE, Claude GRUFFAT, Damien CARÊME, David CORMAND, François ALFONSI, François THIOLLET, Gwendoline DELBOS-CORFIELD, Karima DELLI, Lydie MASSARD, Marie TOUSSAINT, Mounir SATOURI Abstain (1) Benoît BITEAU 12	Italy Verts/ALE Against (3) Ignazio CORRAO, Piernicola PEDICINI, Rosa D'AMATO 3		Czechia Verts/ALE Against (3) Marcel KOLAJA, Markéta GREGOROVÁ, Mikuláš PEKSA 3		Ireland Verts/ALE Against (1) Ciarán CUFFE Abstain (1) Grace O'SULLIVAN 2		Sweden Verts/ALE Against (2) Alice KUHNKE, Pär HOLMGREN 2	Netherlands Verts/ALE Against (3) Bas EICKHOUT, Kim VAN SPARRENTAK, Tineke STRIK 3		Germany Verts/ALE Against (20) Alexandra GEESE, Anna CAVAZZINI, Anna DEPARNAY-GRUNENBERG, Damian BOESELAGER, Daniel FREUND, Erik MARQUARDT, Hannah NEUMANN, Katrin LANGENSIEPEN, Manuela RIPA, Martin HÄUSLING, Michael BLOSS, Nico SEMSROTT, Patrick BREYER, Pierrette HERZBERGER-FOFANA, Rasmus ANDRESEN, Reinhard BÜTIKOFER, Sergey LAGODINSKY, Ska KELLER, Terry REINTKE, Viola VON CRAMON-TAUBADEL 20	Belgium Verts/ALE Against (3) Philippe LAMBERTS, Sara MATTHIEU, Saskia BRICMONT 3		Finland Verts/ALE Against (2) Alviina ALAMETSÄ, Ville NIINISTÖ 2		Denmark Verts/ALE Against (1) Margrete AUKEN 1		Lithuania Verts/ALE For (1) Stasys JAKELIŪNAS Against (1) Bronis ROPĖ 2			Luxembourg Verts/ALE Against (1) Tilly METZ 1	Portugal Verts/ALE Against (1) Francisco GUERREIRO 1		Spain Verts/ALE Against (3) Ana MIRANDA PAZ, Diana RIBA I GINER, Jordi SOLÉ 3	Austria Verts/ALE Against (2) Monika VANA, Thomas WAITZ 2
S&D	107	Poland S&D Against (6) Bogusław LIBERADZKI, Leszek MILLER, Marek Paweł BALT, Robert BIEDROŃ, Włodzimierz CIMOSZEWICZ, Łukasz KOHUT 6	France S&D For (1) Pierre LARROUTUROU Against (6) Aurore LALUCQ, Christophe CLERGEAU, Nora MEBAREK, Pascal DURAND, Raphaël GLUCKSMANN, Sylvie GUILLAUME 7	Italy S&D Against (4) Massimiliano SMERIGLIO, Paolo DE CASTRO, Patrizia TOIA, Pietro BARTOLO Abstain (9) Achille VARIATI, Alessandra MORETTI, Beatrice COVASSI, Brando BENIFEI, Camilla LAURETI, Daniela RONDINELLI, Elisabetta GUALMINI, Franco ROBERTI, Mercedes BRESSO 13	Romania S&D Against (3) Adrian-Dragoş BENEA, Maria GRAPINI, Rovana PLUMB 3	Czechia S&D Against (1) Radka MAXOVÁ 1	Croatia S&D For (4) Biljana BORZAN, Predrag Fred MATIĆ, Romana JERKOVIĆ, Tonino PICULA 4		Slovakia S&D Abstain (1) Robert HAJŠEL 1		Netherlands S&D Against (6) Agnes JONGERIUS, Lara WOLTERS, Mohammed CHAHIM, Paul TANG, Thijs REUTEN, Vera TAX 6	Bulgaria S&D Against (2) Elena YONCHEVA, Petar VITANOV 2	Germany S&D Against (11) Bernd LANGE, Birgit SIPPEL, Dietmar KÖSTER, Gabriele BISCHOFF, Joachim SCHUSTER, Maria NOICHL, Matthias ECKE, René REPASI, Thomas RUDNER, Tiemo WÖLKEN, Udo BULLMANN 11	Belgium S&D Against (2) Kathleen VAN BREMPT, Maria ARENA 2	Hungary S&D Against (3) Attila ARA-KOVÁCS, Klára DOBREV, Sándor RÓNAI 3	Finland S&D Against (1) Miapetra KUMPULA-NATRI 1	Estonia S&D Against (2) Marina KALJURAND, Sven MIKSER 2	Denmark S&D Against (3) Christel SCHALDEMOSE, Marianne VIND, Niels FUGLSANG 3	Slovenia S&D Against (2) Matjaž NEMEC, Milan BRGLEZ 2	Lithuania S&D Against (2) Juozas OLEKAS, Vilija BLINKEVIČIŪTĖ 2	Greece S&D Against (1) Nikos PAPANDREOU 1	Latvia S&D Against (2) Andris AMERIKS, Nils UŠAKOVS 2	Luxembourg S&D Against (1) Marc ANGEL 1	Portugal S&D Against (8) Carlos ZORRINHO, Isabel CARVALHAIS, Isabel SANTOS, Margarida MARQUES, Maria-Manuel LEITÃO-MARQUES, Pedro MARQUES, Pedro SILVA PEREIRA, Sara CERDAS 8	Malta S&D Against (2) Alex AGIUS SALIBA, Alfred SANT 2	Spain S&D Against (19) Alicia HOMS GINEL, Clara AGUILERA, Cristina MAESTRE, César LUENA, Domènec RUIZ DEVESA, Eider GARDIAZABAL RUBIAL, Ibán GARCÍA DEL BLANCO, Inma RODRÍGUEZ-PIÑERO, Iratxe GARCÍA PÉREZ, Isabel GARCÍA MUÑOZ, Javi LÓPEZ, Javier MORENO SÁNCHEZ, Juan Fernando LÓPEZ AGUILAR, Laura BALLARÍN CEREZA, Lina GÁLVEZ, Marcos ROS SEMPERE, Mónica Silvana GONZÁLEZ, Nacho SÁNCHEZ AMOR, Nicolás GONZÁLEZ CASARES 19	Austria S&D Against (5) Andreas SCHIEDER, Evelyn REGNER, Günther SIDL, Hannes HEIDE, Theresa BIELOWSKI 5

B9-0162/2024 – After § 4 – Am 8 #

		PL	FR	IT	CZ	RO	SK	IE	DE	SE	NL	HR	BG	BE	HU	DK	EE	SI	EL	LV	LT	LU	FI	ES	PT	MT	AT
	Total	46	69	51	20	18	10	13	73	14	27	11	11	18	12	10	7	7	4	6	8	5	10	49	17	3	12
PPE	127	Poland PPE For (12) Adam JARUBAS, Andrzej HALICKI, Danuta Maria HÜBNER, Elżbieta Katarzyna ŁUKACIJEWSKA, Ewa KOPACZ, Jan OLBRYCHT, Jarosław DUDA, Jarosław KALINOWSKI, Jerzy BUZEK, Magdalena ADAMOWICZ, Tomasz FRANKOWSKI, Włodzimierz KARPIŃSKI Abstain (1) Witold PAHL 13	France PPE For (7) Anne SANDER, Arnaud DANJEAN, Brice HORTEFEUX, François-Xavier BELLAMY, Laurence SAILLIET, Nadine MORANO, Nathalie COLIN-OESTERLÉ 7	Italy PPE For (8) Caterina CHINNICI, Francesca PEPPUCCI, Herbert DORFMANN, Isabella ADINOLFI, Lucia VUOLO, Matteo GAZZINI, Salvatore DE MEO, Stefania ZAMBELLI 8	Czechia PPE For (5) Jiří POSPÍŠIL, Luděk NIEDERMAYER, Michaela ŠOJDROVÁ, Stanislav POLČÁK, Tomáš ZDECHOVSKÝ 5	Romania PPE For (8) Daniel BUDA, Eugen TOMAC, Iuliu WINKLER, Marian-Jean MARINESCU, Mircea-Gheorghe HAVA, Siegfried MUREŞAN, Traian BĂSESCU, Vasile BLAGA 8	Slovakia PPE For (4) Ivan ŠTEFANEC, Miriam LEXMANN, Peter POLLÁK, Vladimír BILČÍK 4	Ireland PPE For (5) Colm MARKEY, Deirdre CLUNE, Frances FITZGERALD, Maria WALSH, Seán KELLY 5	Germany PPE For (20) Andreas SCHWAB, Angelika NIEBLER, Christian DOLESCHAL, Daniel CASPARY, David MCALLISTER, Karolin BRAUNSBERGER-REINHOLD, Manfred WEBER, Marion WALSMANN, Markus FERBER, Marlene MORTLER, Michael GAHLER, Monika HOHLMEIER, Niels GEUKING, Norbert LINS, Peter JAHR, Peter LIESE, Rainer WIELAND, Ralf SEEKATZ, Sabine VERHEYEN, Sven SIMON 20	Sweden PPE For (5) Arba KOKALARI, Jessica POLFJÄRD, Jörgen WARBORN, Sara SKYTTEDAL, Tomas TOBÉ 5	Netherlands PPE For (5) Anja HAGA, Antonius MANDERS, Henk Jan ORMEL, Jeroen LENAERS, Tom BERENDSEN 5	Croatia PPE For (3) Karlo RESSLER, Sunčana GLAVAK, Tomislav SOKOL 3	Bulgaria PPE For (5) Alexander ALEXANDROV YORDANOV, Andrey KOVATCHEV, Andrey NOVAKOV, Asim ADEMOV, Radan KANEV 5	Belgium PPE For (3) Cindy FRANSSEN, Pascal ARIMONT, Tom VANDENKENDELAERE 3		Denmark PPE For (1) Pernille WEISS 1	Estonia PPE For (1) Riho TERRAS 1	Slovenia PPE For (3) Franc BOGOVIČ, Ljudmila NOVAK, Romana TOMC 3		Latvia PPE For (3) Dace MELBĀRDE, Inese VAIDERE, Sandra KALNIETE 3	Lithuania PPE For (3) Andrius KUBILIUS, Aušra SEIBUTYTĖ, Liudas MAŽYLIS 3	Luxembourg PPE For (1) Martine KEMP 1	Finland PPE For (2) Henna VIRKKUNEN, Petri SARVAMAA Against (1) Sirpa PIETIKÄINEN 3	Spain PPE For (12) Ana COLLADO JIMÉNEZ, Antonio LÓPEZ-ISTÚRIZ WHITE, Dolors MONTSERRAT, Francisco José MILLÁN MON, Gabriel MATO, Isabel BENJUMEA BENJUMEA, Javier ZARZALEJOS, José Manuel GARCÍA-MARGALLO Y MARFIL, Juan Ignacio ZOIDO ÁLVAREZ, Leopoldo LÓPEZ GIL, Pablo ARIAS ECHEVERRÍA, Rosa ESTARÀS FERRAGUT 12	Portugal PPE For (6) Carlos COELHO, Cláudia MONTEIRO DE AGUIAR, José Manuel FERNANDES, Lídia PEREIRA, Maria da Graça CARVALHO, Nuno MELO 6	Malta PPE For (1) David CASA 1	Austria PPE For (2) Barbara THALER, Lukas MANDL 2
Renew	80	Poland Renew For (1) Róża THUN UND HOHENSTEIN 1	France Renew For (20) Bernard GUETTA, Catherine AMALRIC, Catherine CHABAUD, Christophe GRUDLER, Dominique RIQUET, Fabienne KELLER, Gilles BOYER, Guy LAVOCAT, Ilana CICUREL, Irène TOLLERET, Jérémy DECERLE, Laurence FARRENG, Marie-Pierre VEDRENNE, Max ORVILLE, Nathalie LOISEAU, Pascal CANFIN, Salima YENBOU, Sandro GOZI, Stéphanie YON-COURTIN, Valérie HAYER 20	Italy Renew For (3) Fabio Massimo CASTALDO, Giuseppe FERRANDINO, Nicola DANTI 3	Czechia Renew For (4) Dita CHARANZOVÁ, Martin HLAVÁČEK, Ondřej KNOTEK, Ondřej KOVAŘÍK 4	Romania Renew For (5) Alin MITUȚA, Dragoş PÎSLARU, Dragoş TUDORACHE, Vlad GHEORGHE, Vlad-Marius BOTOŞ 5	Slovakia Renew For (1) Michal WIEZIK 1	Ireland Renew For (2) Barry ANDREWS, Billy KELLEHER 2	Germany Renew For (6) Andreas GLÜCK, Engin EROGLU, Jan-Christoph OETJEN, Michael KAUCH, Moritz KÖRNER, Svenja HAHN 6	Sweden Renew For (3) Abir AL-SAHLANI, Emma WIESNER, Karin KARLSBRO 3	Netherlands Renew For (5) Bart GROOTHUIS, Caroline NAGTEGAAL, Jan HUITEMA, Malik AZMANI, Sophia IN 'T VELD Against (1) Catharina RINZEMA 6	Croatia Renew Against (1) Valter FLEGO 1	Bulgaria Renew For (3) Atidzhe ALIEVA-VELI, Ilhan KYUCHYUK, Iskra MIHAYLOVA 3	Belgium Renew For (2) Hilde VAUTMANS, Olivier CHASTEL 2	Hungary Renew For (2) Anna Júlia DONÁTH, Katalin CSEH 2	Denmark Renew For (4) Bergur Løkke RASMUSSEN, Erik POULSEN, Karen MELCHIOR, Morten LØKKEGAARD 4	Estonia Renew For (3) Andrus ANSIP, Jana TOOM, Urmas PAET 3	Slovenia Renew For (2) Irena JOVEVA, Klemen GROŠELJ 2	Greece Renew For (1) Georgios KYRTSOS 1	Latvia Renew For (1) Ivars IJABS 1	Lithuania Renew For (1) Petras AUŠTREVIČIUS 1	Luxembourg Renew For (2) Charles GOERENS, Monica SEMEDO 2	Finland Renew For (2) Mauri PEKKARINEN, Nils TORVALDS 2	Spain Renew For (5) Javier NART, Jordi CAÑAS, José Ramón BAUZÁ DÍAZ, Maite PAGAZAURTUNDÚA, María Soraya RODRÍGUEZ RAMOS 5
ECR	53	Poland ECR For (25) Adam BIELAN, Andżelika Anna MOŻDŻANOWSKA, Anna FOTYGA, Anna ZALEWSKA, Beata KEMPA, Beata MAZUREK, Beata SZYDŁO, Bogdan RZOŃCA, Dominik TARCZYŃSKI, Elżbieta KRUK, Elżbieta RAFALSKA, Grzegorz TOBISZOWSKI, Izabela-Helena KLOC, Jacek SARYUSZ-WOLSKI, Jadwiga WIŚNIEWSKA, Joachim Stanisław BRUDZIŃSKI, Joanna KOPCIŃSKA, Kosma ZŁOTOWSKI, Krzysztof JURGIEL, Patryk JAKI, Rafał ROMANOWSKI, Ryszard CZARNECKI, Tomasz Piotr PORĘBA, Witold Jan WASZCZYKOWSKI, Zdzisław KRASNODĘBSKI 25	France ECR For (1) Nicolas BAY 1	Italy ECR For (3) Denis NESCI, Elisabetta DE BLASIS, Sergio BERLATO 3	Czechia ECR For (4) Alexandr VONDRA, Evžen TOŠENOVSKÝ, Jan ZAHRADIL, Veronika VRECIONOVÁ 4	Romania ECR For (1) Cristian TERHEŞ 1	Slovakia ECR For (1) Eugen JURZYCA 1		Germany ECR For (1) Lars Patrick BERG 1	Sweden ECR For (3) Charlie WEIMERS, Johan NISSINEN, Peter LUNDGREN 3	Netherlands ECR For (5) Bert-Jan RUISSEN, Dorien ROOKMAKER, Michiel HOOGEVEEN, Rob ROOKEN, Robert ROOS 5	Croatia ECR For (1) Ladislav ILČIĆ 1	Bulgaria ECR For (1) Andrey SLABAKOV 1	Belgium ECR For (3) Assita KANKO, Geert BOURGEOIS, Johan VAN OVERTVELDT 3									Finland ECR For (1) Pirkko RUOHONEN-LERNER 1	Spain ECR For (3) Hermann TERTSCH, Jorge BUXADÉ VILLALBA, Margarita DE LA PISA CARRIÓN 3
ID	49		France ID For (17) André ROUGÉ, Annika BRUNA, Aurélia BEIGNEUX, Catherine GRISET, Dominique BILDE, Eric MINARDI, France JAMET, Gilles LEBRETON, Jean-Lin LACAPELLE, Jean-Paul GARRAUD, Jordan BARDELLA, Marie DAUCHY, Mathilde ANDROUËT, Patricia CHAGNON, Philippe OLIVIER, Thierry MARIANI, Virginie JORON 17	Italy ID For (15) Alessandra BASSO, Alessandro PANZA, Anna BONFRISCO, Antonio Maria RINALDI, Elena LIZZI, Gianantonio DA RE, Gianna GANCIA, Marco CAMPOMENOSI, Marco ZANNI, Maria Veronica ROSSI, Matteo ADINOLFI, Paola GHIDONI, Rosanna CONTE, Silvia SARDONE, Susanna CECCARDI 15	Czechia ID For (1) Ivan DAVID 1				Germany ID For (8) Bernhard ZIMNIOK, Christine ANDERSON, Guido REIL, Gunnar BECK, Joachim KUHS, Markus BUCHHEIT, Nicolaus FEST, Sylvia LIMMER 8					Belgium ID For (3) Filip DE MAN, Gerolf ANNEMANS, Tom VANDENDRIESSCHE 3		Denmark ID For (1) Anders VISTISEN 1	Estonia ID For (1) Jaak MADISON 1										Austria ID For (3) Georg MAYER, Harald VILIMSKY, Roman HAIDER 3
NI	30		France NI For (1) Hervé JUVIN 1	Italy NI For (5) Laura FERRARA, Maria Angela DANZÌ, Mario FURORE, Sabrina PIGNEDOLI, Tiziana BEGHIN Against (1) Dino GIARRUSSO 6	Czechia NI For (1) Hynek BLAŠKO 1	Romania NI For (1) Tudor CIUHODARU 1	Slovakia NI For (3) Katarína ROTH NEVEĎALOVÁ, Milan UHRÍK, Miroslav RADAČOVSKÝ 3		Germany NI For (1) Jörg MEUTHEN Against (1) Martin SONNEBORN 2		Netherlands NI For (1) Marcel de GRAAFF 1	Croatia NI For (2) Ivan Vilibor SINČIĆ, Mislav KOLAKUŠIĆ 2		Belgium NI Against (1) Marc TARABELLA 1	Hungary NI For (7) Andor DELI, Andrea BOCSKOR, Edina TÓTH, Enikő GYŐRI, Ernő SCHALLER-BAROSS, Kinga GÁL, Márton GYÖNGYÖSI 7				Greece NI For (2) Athanasios KONSTANTINOU, Eva KAILI 2					Spain NI Against (3) Antoni COMÍN I OLIVERES, Carles PUIGDEMONT I CASAMAJÓ, Clara PONSATÍ OBIOLS 3
The Left	23		France The Left For (1) Anne-Sophie PELLETIER Against (3) Leila CHAIBI, Manon AUBRY, Marina MESURE 4		Czechia The Left For (1) Kateřina KONEČNÁ 1			Ireland The Left For (4) Chris MACMANUS, Clare DALY, Luke Ming FLANAGAN, Mick WALLACE 4	Germany The Left For (3) Cornelia ERNST, Helmut SCHOLZ, Özlem DEMIREL Against (1) Martina MICHELS 4	Sweden The Left Against (1) Malin BJÖRK 1	Netherlands The Left For (1) Anja HAZEKAMP 1			Belgium The Left For (1) Marc BOTENGA 1		Denmark The Left For (1) Nikolaj VILLUMSEN 1								Spain The Left For (4) Esther SANZ SELVA, Eugenia RODRÍGUEZ PALOP, Idoia VILLANUEVA RUIZ, Patricia CARO MAYA 4	Portugal The Left For (2) José GUSMÃO, Marisa MATIAS 2
Verts/ALE	62	Poland Verts/ALE Against (1) Sylwia SPUREK 1	France Verts/ALE Against (12) Benoît BITEAU, Caroline ROOSE, Claude GRUFFAT, Damien CARÊME, David CORMAND, François ALFONSI, François THIOLLET, Gwendoline DELBOS-CORFIELD, Karima DELLI, Lydie MASSARD, Marie TOUSSAINT, Mounir SATOURI 12	Italy Verts/ALE Against (3) Ignazio CORRAO, Piernicola PEDICINI, Rosa D'AMATO 3	Czechia Verts/ALE For (3) Marcel KOLAJA, Markéta GREGOROVÁ, Mikuláš PEKSA 3			Ireland Verts/ALE Against (2) Ciarán CUFFE, Grace O'SULLIVAN 2	Germany Verts/ALE For (1) Patrick BREYER Against (18) Alexandra GEESE, Anna CAVAZZINI, Anna DEPARNAY-GRUNENBERG, Damian BOESELAGER, Daniel FREUND, Erik MARQUARDT, Hannah NEUMANN, Katrin LANGENSIEPEN, Manuela RIPA, Martin HÄUSLING, Michael BLOSS, Nico SEMSROTT, Pierrette HERZBERGER-FOFANA, Rasmus ANDRESEN, Sergey LAGODINSKY, Ska KELLER, Terry REINTKE, Viola VON CRAMON-TAUBADEL Abstain (1) Reinhard BÜTIKOFER 20	Sweden Verts/ALE Against (2) Alice KUHNKE, Pär HOLMGREN 2	Netherlands Verts/ALE Against (3) Bas EICKHOUT, Kim VAN SPARRENTAK, Tineke STRIK 3			Belgium Verts/ALE Against (3) Philippe LAMBERTS, Sara MATTHIEU, Saskia BRICMONT 3		Denmark Verts/ALE Against (1) Margrete AUKEN 1					Lithuania Verts/ALE For (1) Stasys JAKELIŪNAS Against (1) Bronis ROPĖ 2	Luxembourg Verts/ALE Against (1) Tilly METZ 1	Finland Verts/ALE Against (3) Alviina ALAMETSÄ, Heidi HAUTALA, Ville NIINISTÖ 3	Spain Verts/ALE Against (3) Ana MIRANDA PAZ, Diana RIBA I GINER, Jordi SOLÉ 3	Portugal Verts/ALE Against (1) Francisco GUERREIRO 1		Austria Verts/ALE Against (2) Monika VANA, Thomas WAITZ 2
S&D	107	Poland S&D Against (6) Bogusław LIBERADZKI, Leszek MILLER, Marek Paweł BALT, Robert BIEDROŃ, Włodzimierz CIMOSZEWICZ, Łukasz KOHUT 6	France S&D For (1) Pierre LARROUTUROU Against (6) Aurore LALUCQ, Christophe CLERGEAU, Nora MEBAREK, Pascal DURAND, Raphaël GLUCKSMANN, Sylvie GUILLAUME 7	Italy S&D Against (3) Massimiliano SMERIGLIO, Paolo DE CASTRO, Pietro BARTOLO Abstain (10) Achille VARIATI, Alessandra MORETTI, Beatrice COVASSI, Brando BENIFEI, Camilla LAURETI, Daniela RONDINELLI, Elisabetta GUALMINI, Franco ROBERTI, Mercedes BRESSO, Patrizia TOIA 13	Czechia S&D Against (1) Radka MAXOVÁ 1	Romania S&D Against (3) Adrian-Dragoş BENEA, Maria GRAPINI, Rovana PLUMB 3	Slovakia S&D Abstain (1) Robert HAJŠEL 1		Germany S&D Against (12) Bernd LANGE, Birgit SIPPEL, Dietmar KÖSTER, Gabriele BISCHOFF, Jens GEIER, Joachim SCHUSTER, Maria NOICHL, Matthias ECKE, René REPASI, Thomas RUDNER, Tiemo WÖLKEN, Udo BULLMANN 12		Netherlands S&D Against (6) Agnes JONGERIUS, Lara WOLTERS, Mohammed CHAHIM, Paul TANG, Thijs REUTEN, Vera TAX 6	Croatia S&D For (3) Biljana BORZAN, Predrag Fred MATIĆ, Tonino PICULA Against (1) Romana JERKOVIĆ 4	Bulgaria S&D Against (2) Elena YONCHEVA, Petar VITANOV 2	Belgium S&D Against (2) Kathleen VAN BREMPT, Maria ARENA 2	Hungary S&D Against (3) Attila ARA-KOVÁCS, Klára DOBREV, Sándor RÓNAI 3	Denmark S&D Against (2) Christel SCHALDEMOSE, Niels FUGLSANG 2	Estonia S&D Against (2) Marina KALJURAND, Sven MIKSER 2	Slovenia S&D Against (2) Matjaž NEMEC, Milan BRGLEZ 2	Greece S&D Against (1) Nikos PAPANDREOU 1	Latvia S&D Against (2) Andris AMERIKS, Nils UŠAKOVS 2	Lithuania S&D Against (2) Juozas OLEKAS, Vilija BLINKEVIČIŪTĖ 2	Luxembourg S&D Against (1) Marc ANGEL 1	Finland S&D Against (1) Miapetra KUMPULA-NATRI 1	Spain S&D Against (19) Alicia HOMS GINEL, Clara AGUILERA, Cristina MAESTRE, César LUENA, Domènec RUIZ DEVESA, Eider GARDIAZABAL RUBIAL, Ibán GARCÍA DEL BLANCO, Inma RODRÍGUEZ-PIÑERO, Iratxe GARCÍA PÉREZ, Isabel GARCÍA MUÑOZ, Javi LÓPEZ, Javier MORENO SÁNCHEZ, Juan Fernando LÓPEZ AGUILAR, Laura BALLARÍN CEREZA, Lina GÁLVEZ, Marcos ROS SEMPERE, Mónica Silvana GONZÁLEZ, Nacho SÁNCHEZ AMOR, Nicolás GONZÁLEZ CASARES 19	Portugal S&D Against (8) Carlos ZORRINHO, Isabel CARVALHAIS, Isabel SANTOS, Margarida MARQUES, Maria-Manuel LEITÃO-MARQUES, Pedro MARQUES, Pedro SILVA PEREIRA, Sara CERDAS 8	Malta S&D Against (2) Alex AGIUS SALIBA, Alfred SANT 2	Austria S&D Against (5) Andreas SCHIEDER, Evelyn REGNER, Günther SIDL, Hannes HEIDE, Theresa BIELOWSKI 5